Thursday, Mar. 15, 2007 Where Doctors Go Wrong By Christine Gorman The patient was an 8-year-old California girl with severe headaches. Her parents, who were both struggling to adjust to new high-pressure jobs, took her to top neurologists and pediatricians. The child's symptoms, the doctors concluded, were a response to stress at home, along with perhaps a sinus condition. But four or five months later, it became clear that she had a brain tumor and needed surgery. When her doctors looked back at early scans of her brain, they were aghast to see the shadow of a tumor they had previously overlooked. For Harvard hematologist Jerome Groopman, who is a friend of the child's parents, the missed diagnosis was more than just a cautionary tale. It was the start of an investigative journey. "People talk about technical errors in medicine, but no one talks about thinking errors," he explains in an interview. "I realized I had no framework for understanding these kinds of problems." For the next three years--in addition to seeing patients and doing research, plus his gig as a staff writer for the New Yorker--Groopman began to intensively examine how doctors think and how they get sidetracked from the truth. He learned that about 80% of medical mistakes are the result of predictable mental traps, or cognitive errors, that bedevil all human beings. Only 20% are due to technical mishaps--mixed-up test results or hard-to-decipher handwriting--that typically loom larger in patients' minds and on television shows. The result of Groopman's journey is How Doctors Think (Houghton Mifflin; 307 pages), an engagingly written book that is must reading for every physician who cares for patients and every patient who wishes to get the best care. Groopman says patients can prompt broader, sharper and less prejudiced thinking by asking doctors open-ended questions and learning to identify some of their common thinking mistakes: ERROR 1: I RECOGNIZE THE TYPE Doctors, like most of us, are often led astray by stereotypes that are based on someone's appearance, emotional state or circumstances. Thus a homeless man's disorientation might be quickly attributed to alcoholism when the real culprit is diabetes. Groopman describes this kind of "attribution error" in the case of a nervous young woman who kept losing weight even when prescribed a high-calorie diet. Her doctors, convinced that she was lying about her food intake, suspected anorexia or bulimia, but her problem, diagnosed after years of ill health, turned out to be celiac disease--an allergy to wheat. Had the patient been male or older or less anxious, the doctors might have got it right in the first place. ERROR 2: I JUST SAW A CASE LIKE THIS "We all tend to be influenced by the last experience we had or something that made a deep impression on us," Groopman says. So if it's January, your doctor has just seen 14 patients with

the flu and you show up with muscle aches and a fever, he or she is more likely to say you have the flu--which is fine unless it's really meningitis or a reaction to a tetanus shot that you forgot to mention. The best defense--besides giving as complete a history as you can--is to be alert and ready to ask questions anytime a doctor says, "There's a lot of this going around." ERROR 3: I'VE GOT TO DO SOMETHING Physicians typically prefer to act even when in doubt about the nature of the problem. And yet this kind of "commission bias" can lead to all sorts of new problems if the treatment turns out to be incorrect. "Don't just do something. Stand there," one of Groopman's mentors told him years ago when he was uncertain of a diagnosis. This buys a doctor time to think--which is especially important when trying to ensure that something hasn't been overlooked. ERROR 4: I HATE (OR LOVE) THIS PATIENT Groopman cautions that emotions are more of an issue than most physicians like to admit. Doctors who are particularly fond of a patient have been known to miss the diagnosis of a lifethreatening cancer because they just didn't want it to be true. But negative emotions can be just as blinding, sometimes stopping a doctor from going the extra mile. "If you sense that your doctor is irritated with you, that he or she doesn't like you," says Groopman, "then it's time to get a new doctor." Studies show that most patients are pretty accurate in describing their doctors' feelings toward them. Groopman's book makes abundantly clear that despite all the electronic databases that are being used to improve health care, a lot of medicine still comes down to a doctor or two puzzling out what might be wrong with your body. Experience, common assumptions and human nature can guide them or lead them astray. By asking a few questions--especially if you think your doctor isn't asking enough of them--you can raise the odds that your physician won't get detoured from the truth.

Thursday, Mar

Mar 15, 2007 - But four or five months later, it became clear that she had a brain tumor ... ERROR 4: I HATE (OR LOVE) THIS PATIENT ... feelings toward them.

14KB Sizes 0 Downloads 369 Views

Recommend Documents

Thursday, Mar. 15, 2007 Where Doctors Go Wrong By ...
Mar 15, 2007 - The patient was an 8-year-old California girl with severe headaches. Her parents, who were both struggling to adjust to new high-pressure jobs, took her to top neurologists and pediatricians. The child's symptoms, the doctors concluded

Constitution Thursday - WordPress.com
May 13, 2015 - 1.2 Service during the Revolutionary War . ...... mostly in vain, to recruit additional soldiers and protect the state from raiders from Philadelphia ...... apply…”[62] During the convention, Hamilton constructed a draft for the Co

Maundy Thursday Reflection A4
“One of you will betray me.” 4 ... He will be betrayed by a friend, one who sat with him as he dined that night had already put plans in .... love will triumph over all.

Maundy Thursday Reflection A4
He had told them that on the night before their liberation they should eat a hasty meal. • With sandals on their feet, they were to eat bread made in haste without ...

Constitution Thursday - WordPress.com
May 13, 2015 - From a slow start, Ellsworth built up a prosperous law prac- tice. In 1777, he became Connecticut's state attorney for. Hartford County. That same year, he was chosen as one of. Connecticut's representatives in the Continental Congress

Thursday, May 19, 2011 - GitHub
May 19, 2011 - ... actually do when we are doing our day-to-day jobs and what we think we should do. ... messages, lists, blocks. TDD - Red, Green, Refactor.

Thursday Psychoeducation Flyer.pdf
There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. Thursday ...

Maundy Thursday - Bulletin.pdf
There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. Maundy ...

Mar-Suit.pdf
(609) 646-0222 FAX (609) 646-0887. Attorneys for Plaintiff ... a/k/a GATEWAY COMMUNITY ACTION. PARTNERSHIP; EAS .... Mar-Suit.pdf. Mar-Suit.pdf. Open.

Mar. Newsletter.pdf
showing locations of. the scenes in a novel,. for instance. ... a new cell phone model), have him jot it. down on the correct day. Then ... feels pressured to do. something that makes. her uncomfortable. Parent to Parent. Q. &. A. Page 2 of 2. Mar. N

Mar 2005
Mar 1, 2005 - quick and economical way. ... a paragraph or two from the full text to give you some idea about it; .... Do I not destroy them when I make them my friends?" (3) ... A budget is just a method of worrying before you spend money, ...

Mar.2018menu.pdf
Chicken salad wrap. 22 Breakfast pizza bagel. LUNCH SPECIAL. Sloppy joes. On fresh baked bun. DELI OPTION. Ham deli sandwich. 23 French toast. LUNCH SPECIAL. Hotdog on homemade bun. Baked beans/coleslaw. DELI OPTION. Homemade soup/roll. 26 Sausage pa

1.01/12/2016 Thursday 07.30 AM to 09.15 AM 2.01/12/2016 Thursday ...
Dec 1, 2016 - Part I:Questions based on Educational Qualification. Part II:General ... TRADESMAN(TURNING)TECHNICAL EDUCATION DEPARTMENT.

Mar - Apr.pdf
This was held on Saturday, February 4th at Campbell Auto Services on S. Saunders ... th Meeting: Club ... Sunday, April 9th Location: Charlotte Motor Speedway.

Mar 2005
Mar 1, 2005 - (CA Cancer J Clin 2005; 55:31-44). American Cancer ... 1 Animal Biochemistry Division, National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal - 132 001,.

Mar-NM.PDF
Attorneys for Defendants, James Curtis Edwards, City of Bridgeton and Jack Surrency. THOMAS ... JAMES CURTIS EDWARDS; CITY OF ... NEHMAD, PERILLO & DAVIS, P.C. ... m4 R5 H;4 LL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEM4N & GOGGIN.

MAR Elementary.pdf
Yogurt Parfait. Teriyaki Chicken w/ Rice. Hot Dog. PB&J Sandwich. Mini Pancakes. English Muffin w/ Sausage. Cheeseburger. Popcorn Chicken. Turkey Sub Sandwich. Frudel. English Muffin w/ Egg & Bacon. Hamburger. Pepperoni Pizza. Ham Sub Sandwich. Mini

Mar-Resignation.pdf
CompleteCare as a future Board member. Once again, I thank you for the opportunity to have been of service. R'• 711,V. -,. Edwards. cc: Albert B. Kelly, President; Edward Bethea, Executive Vice President; and John Washington,. Chairman/Board of Dir

Thursday, 3 May 2018 - Lagardère
4 days ago - Supervisory Board for a term of four years. Resolution n° 8 – Re-appointment of Yves Guillemot as a member of the Supervisory. Board for a term of four years. Resolution n° 9 – Re-appointment of Patrick Valroff as a member of the S

Thursday, January 8, 2015 -
Jan 8, 2015 - The Veterans Legal Clinic at Syracuse University is the first and only comprehensive legal clinic in New York providing free legal assistance to ...

Thursday, October 24, 2013, Albuquerque ... -
Crimes Against Children Unit, Attorney General's. Office. • School Mental Health: Approaches to create zones of safety and reduce stigma– Yolanda. Cordova, Director, Office of School and. Adolescent, New Mexico Department of Health;. Jenn Jeverts

Thursday Letter November 16.pdf
Page 1 of 1. Page 1 of 1. Thursday Letter November 16.pdf. Thursday Letter November 16.pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In. Main menu. Page 1 of 1.

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday ...
A. B. C. D. E. F. G. H. I. J. K. L. M. N. O. P. Q. R. S. T. U. V. W. X. Y. Z. Monday. Tuesday. Wednesday. Thursday. Friday. Saturday. Sunday. It's sunny. It's raining. It's windy. It's cloudy. It's snowing. January. February. March. April. May. June.

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sunday
Monday. Tuesday Wednesday Thursday. Friday. Saturday. Sunday. 8:00 AM. 9:00 AM. 10:00 AM Regular Health. Tai Chi. Entry Level. Qi Gong. Regular Health.