Sequential Auctions with Supply Uncertainty

Viewer
Transcript

5i^i?|@* U|L?t | 5TT*) N?Uih|@?|) @* i3@?tht|L w@MLh@|Lh) uLh , Tih4i?|@* ,UL?L4Ut N?iht|) Lu L?? _i?@ih@**ii 2ee2 #D L??c Bih4@?) i4@*G T@*9*@MiUL??ML??_i At ihtL?G a*) bb.

Devwudfw Wkh sxusrvh ri wklv sdshu lv wr dqdo|vh wkh lpsdfw ri vxsso| xqfhuwdlqw| rq wkh irupdwlrq ri sulfhv dqg rq wkh vhoohu*v h{shfwhg uhyhqxh lq vhtxhqwldo uvw0 dqg vhfrqg0 sulfh vhdohg elg dxfwlrqv1 Dwwhqwlrq lv sdlg wr wkh vhoohu*v rswlpdo srolf| uhjduglqj wkh uhohdvh ru zlwkkroglqj ri lqirupdwlrq derxw wkh dydlodeoh vxsso|/ wr wkh ex|huv* vwudwhjlf lqihuhqfhv derxw wkh vhoohu*v frqfhdolqj srolf| dqg wr wkh uhvxowlqj vhtxhqfh ri h{shfwhg sulfhv1 D fdvh zkhuh wkh vhoohu frpplwv klpvhoi wr eh xqdzduh ri wkh dydlodeoh vxsso| iru vdoh lv dovr frqvlghuhg1 Lw lv vkrzq wkdw vxfk d frpplwphqw/ zklfk kdv ehhq hpslulfdoo| revhuyhg/ pd| ohdg wkh vhoohu wr lqfuhdvh/ ghfuhdvh ru wr pdlqwdlq klv orqj uxq h{shfwhg uhyhqxh htxdo wr wkh rqh rewdlqhg li wkh dydlodeoh vxsso| zdv dozd|v uhsruwhg1

MHO Fodvvlfdwlrq Qxpehuv= G77/ G;4/ G;5 Nh|zrugv= Pxowl0xqlw Dxfwlrqv/ Sulydwh0Lqghshqghqw Ydoxhv/ Xqfhuwdlqw|1 L

dp wr judwhixo Urqdog Kduvwdg dqg Dodq Nlupdq iru khosixo frpphqwv rq dq hduolhu gudiw1 Uhpdlqlqj

huuruv duh p| rzq1

W?|hL_U|L?

W? t thi) Lu @hLt hi@*Lh*_ @U|L? 4@h!i|tc @tt@_) EbS. hiTLh|t |i i t|i?Ui Lu @U|L?t ihi ti**iht |L*_ uhL4 M)iht @?) ?uLh4@|L? UL?Uih??} |i @4L?| Lu tTT*) @@*@M*i uLh t@*i 5U Th@U|Ui @t Mii? LMtihi_ ? t 4@h!i|t tU @t |Lti Lu OL?! kL?}c Ai* c O@u@c @?*@ @?_ Lu |i 6hi?U 4i_|ihh@?i@? UL@t|*?i ? |i 4@h!i| Lu 5 i|i uLh i @4T*ic |i @U|L? t|@h|t @t |i ht| |h@*ih _ti4M@h!tc |i 4ihU@?_ti t Lgihi_ ? *L|t Lu @ Uih|@? ?4Mih Lu !*Lt Lu @ }i? tTiUit ,@U Lu |iti *L|t t |i? U@hhi_ L? @ 4L?} Mi*| uhL4 |i t|LhihLL4 |L |i M)iht @?_ @__|L?@* tTT*) t _tT*@)i_c ? |i t@4i @)c @UULh_?} |L |i ML@|t< Lh_ih Lu @hh@* )iht U@? |t L?*) tii |i Lgih?}t @t |i @U|L?iih t|@h|t |i @U|L?c |L| uh|ih ?uLh4@|L? @ML| |i _@)
Thiti?Ui Lu ?Uih|@?|) @ML| |i @U|@* tTT*) |L Mi @U|L?i_ ? ti^i?|@* @U|L?t Ai ThTLti Lu |i Thiti?| T@Tih t |L @?@*)ti |i 4T@U| Lu tTT*) ?Uih|@?|) L? |i uLh4@|L? Lu ThUit @?_ L? |i ti**ih
doldwhg ydoxhv frqfhsw zdv lqwurgxfhg e| Plojurp dqg Zhehu ^4<;5d`/ lwv ihdwxuh ehlqj wr surylgh

d pruh jhqhudo iudphzrun doorzlqj iru qrq0qhjdwlyh fruuhodwlrqv dprqj elgghuv* ydoxhv1

@U|L?t @?_ |@| | |i @tt4T|L? Lu _iUhi@t?} @MtL*|i ht! @ihtL?c M)iht L*_ |i? h@?_L43i |ih M_t tL |@| |i @**LU@|L? Lu }LL_t L*_ ?L| ?iUitt@h*) Mi iUi?| @?_ i TiU|i_ ThUit L*_ ?L| ?iUitt@h*) _iU*?i *@U! @?_ #i i3@ Ebb2 _ii*LTi_ @ |L TihL_ 5 @U|L? 4L_i* ihi ? i@U TihL_ L?i |i4 @t Lgihi_ uLh t@*i @?_ ihi i@U M)ihc UL?_|L?@* L? ???} |i ht| TihL_ @U|L?c @t }i? |i LT|L? |L M) |i hi4@??} |i4 @| |i ht| TihL_ ThUi 5U Th@U|Ui @t ?_ii_ Mii? LMtihi_ @| tL4i ?i @U|L?t Ai) tLi_ |@| u M)iht @*i |i ht| |i4 4Lhi |@? |i tiUL?_c tU @? LT|L? L*_ h@ti |i ti**ih
^4<;<` uhsruwv krzhyhu wkdw wklv ex|hu*v rswlrq kdv ehhq dgrswhg e| ydulrxv dxfwlrq krxvhv

suhflvho| wr dwwhqxdwh wklv ghfolqlqj sulfh skhqrphqrq dqg wkdw revhuyhg sulfhv dsshdu wr ghfuhdvh pruh vhyhuho| lq dxfwlrqv zkhuh vxfk dq rswlrq lv devhqw1 6 Wkh

frqfhsw ri cpruh glvshuvhg rughu vwdwlvwlfv* pd| ru pd| qrw eh ghshqgdqw ri fkdqjhv lq wkh phdq1

e

W? B@*i @?_ O@tU Ebbec |L M)iht UL4Ti|i uLh |i ThU@ti Lu L?i Lu |L t|LU@t |U@**) i^@*i?| |i4t tL*_ ? @ ti^i?Ui Lu 5 @U|L?t Bi? |@| Th@|i @*it uLh ML| |i4t @hi !?L? @| |i L|ti| Lu |i @U|L? tittL?c |i @|Lht _ihi_ UL?_|L?t ?_ih U | 4@) Mi LT|4@* uLh @ TL|i?|@* M__ih |L tM4| |i 4?44 @UUiT|@M*i M_ ? |i ht| @U|L? Lh ii? |L ?L| i?|ih ? UL4Ti||L? uLh |i ht| |i4 t |i L|UL4i 4}| |i? *i@_ |L @? ?iUi?| @**LU@|L?c | t tL? |@| M) *i||?} |i ??ih Lu |i ht| @U|L? ULLti t Thiuihhi_ |i4 E@ h}||LULLti< 5 @U|L?c |t L*_ ?iUitt@h*) )i*_ iUi?U) @?_ _iU*??} i TiU|i_ ThUit 6h|ih4Lhic |i |hi?_ Lu ThUit ? ti^i? |@* 5 @U|L?t @?_ |i _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? i TiU|i_ hii?it uLh |i ti**ih uhL4 5 @?_ h}||LULLti< 5 @U|L?t @i |i t@4i t}? W? @| uL**Ltc W t@** hiuih |L *}hL4 @?_ `iMih
D

|i M)iht< T_@|i_ M__?} t|h@|i}it 4@) )i*_ 4 @ *Lih i TiU|i_ hii?i |@? @| i ?|@**) i TiU|i_ @?_ ThL_Ui @ ti^i?Ui Lu i TiU|i_ ThUit U t !?!i_< Ei ht| UL?t|@?| @?_ |i? _iU*??} Aiti hit*|t i |i?_ |L U@tit ihi M)iht @i hL?} Mi*iut @ML| |i @U|@* h@?_L4?itt Lu tTT*) Ei |i) @hi i|ih |LL LT|4t|U< Lh |LL Titt4t|U< 6h|ih4Lhic @ ?4ihU@* i @4T*i tLt |@| ? |i *L?} h? Ei L? @ih@}ic tU @ 4)LTU _iUtL? uLh |i ti**ih L*_ )i*_ 4 @ }ih i TiU|i_ hii?i i? M)iht @hi Titt4t|U @ML| |i @U|@* h@?_L4?itt Lu tTT*)c @ *Lih L?i u |iti @hi t*}|*) LT|4t|U @ML| | @?_ |i t@4i i TiU|i_ hii?i @t |i L?i LM|@?i_ ? |i tTT*) Uih|@?|) uh@4iLh! u M)iht @i i|ih @ ULhhiU| Lh @ ih) LT|4t|U Mi*iu Ai tiUL?_ ti||?} hiuiht |L @ U@ti ihi |i ti**ih t ?@@hi Lu |i @@*@M*i tTT*) |L Mi T| T uLh t@*i 5U @ t|@|L? @t Mii? i4ThU@**) LMtihi_ ? |i @MLi 4i?|L?i_ 6hi?U t 4@h!i|t ?i hi@tL? uLh |t |L @TTi? t |i i t|i?Ui Lu |4i @?_%Lh Lh}@?3@|L?@* UL?t|h@?|t ?_ih U |i ti**?} @t |L LUUh W? |iti t 4@h!i|tc U @hi Lh}@?3i_ L? @ ti^i?|@* #|U @U|L? M@ttc |ihi U*i@h*) @hi |4i UL?t|h@?|t uLh M)iht L Lu|i? ?ii_ |L |h@?tTLh| |ih 4ihU@?_ti i*tiihi M) @ Uih|@? |4ic @?_ _LU!?} *4|@|L?t uLh |h@*iht EU @hi LM*}i_ |L _ti4M@h! ? ti^i?Ui ?L|ih U@h@U|iht|U Lu |iti 4@h!i|t t |@| |i @U|L?iih Thii?|t M)iht uhL4 _h@?} @?) Lu |i ThiLt t|h@|i}U ?uihi?Uit M) UL44||?} 4ti*u |L Mi ?@@hi Lu |i ^@?||it Lu t |L Mi tL*_ W| ** Mi tL? ihi |@| i? |i M)iht< Mi*iu t |@!i? ?|L @UUL?|c tU @ UL44|4i?| uLh |i ti**ih 4@) *i@_ 4 |L i|ih ?Uhi@tic _iUhi@ti Lh 4@?|@? t *L?} h? i TiU|i_ hii?i i^@* |L |i L?i LM|@?i_ i? |i @@*@M*i tTT*) t @*@)t hiTLh|i_ Ai uL**L?} tiU|L? Thiti?|t |i 4L_i* 5)44i|hU i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it @?_ |hi?_t Lu ThUit @hi _i|ih4?i_ ? 5iU|L? 5iU|L? e i T*Lhit |L t|@|L?t ihi |i ti**ih Mi@it t|h@|i}U@**) | hitTiU| |L |i hi*i@ti Lh |L*_?} Lu ?uLh4@|L? @ML| |i @U|@* tTT*) |L Mi @U|L?i_ @?_ 5iU|L? D UL?U*_it |i T@Tih

S

2

AiLhi|U@* uh@4iLh!

tt4i |@| ? : 2 ht!?i|h@* M)iht @||i?_ @ 4@h!i| ihi & ? L4L}i?iLt |i4t @hi |L Mi tL*_ ? @ ti^i?Ui Lu @U|L?t | |i i?_ Lu i@U @U|L?c L?i ?| ** Mi @@h_i_ |L |i M)ih L tM4||i_ |i }it| M_ ,@U M)ih @t Th@|i ?uLh4@|L? UL?Uih??} t L? @*i % uLh |i |i4 |L Mi tL*_ ** @*it @hi h@?_L4*) @?_ ?_iTi?_i?|*) _h@? uhL4 @ }i? ThLM@M*|) _t|hM|L? u?U|L? 8 c U @t @ UL?|?Lt _i?t|) s _i?i_ L? df( n4 )iht @i ?| _i4@?_tG i@U Lu |i4 _ithit L?*) L?i ?| Lu |i |i4t Lgihi_ uLh t@*i N?Uih|@?|) @ML| |L|@* tTT*) t ?|hL_Ui_ M) @tt4?} |@| |ihi t @ 4@ 44 ?4Mih & Lu |i4t |L Mi @U|L?i_ @?_ |@| @| |i i?_ Lu i@U @U|L? hL?_ | &c L?i 4Lhi t@*i 4@) LUUh | ThLM@M*|) B 5 Ef( W| t @*tL @tt4i_ |@| ?c &c B @?_ 8 @hi UL44L? !?L*i_}i |L @** M)iht @?_ |@| L?*) |i ???} M_ t hii@*i_ @| |i i?_ Lu i@U @U|L? hL?_ t 4Lt| hit*|t hiuih |L Lh_ih t|@|t|Utc |i h@?_L4 @h@M*i fE E@?_ |t hi@*3@|L? %E t|@?_ uLh |i | }it| Lu ? _ _h@t uhL4 8 c tL |@| fE fE2 fE?

,^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it @?_ |hi?_ Lu ThUit

W? @ 6 @U|L?c |i |i4 t @@h_i_ |L |i }it| M__ih uLh @ ThUi i^@* |L t M_ 5L*_ |ihi Mi L?*) L?i |i4 |L Mi tL*_c VU!hi) EbS tLi_ |@| @ t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) L*_ Mi uLh @ M)ih |L tM4| @ M_ i^@* |L |i i TiU|@|L? Lu |i tiUL?_ }it| @*i }i? |@| i t tTTLti_ |L @i |i }it| L?i A@| t KE% ' .ifE2 mfE ' %j W? @ 5 @U|L?c t?Ui |i }it| M__ih t @@h_i_ |i |i4 uLh @ ThUi i^@* |L |i tiUL?_ }it| M_c | t @ _L4?@?| t|h@|i}) uLh @ M__ih |L tM4| @ M_ i^@* |L t @*i | i^*Mh4c |i ThUi T@_ M) |i ??ih t |t i^@* |L %E2 6Lh & : @?_ B ' c `iMih EbH tLi_ |@| ? @ ti^i?Ui Lu & @U|L?t @ M__ih
.

}it| @*i }i? |@| t @*@|L? t |i || }it| ? 6 @U|L?t Ei .ifE&n mfE| ' %jc Lh |i E| n | }it| L?i ? 5 @U|L?t Ei .ifE&n mfE|n ' %j Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? }i?ih@*3it |iti hit*|t |L U@tit ihi B 5 Ef( hLTLt|L? G wi| & Mi |i 4@ 44 TLttM*i ?4Mih Lu |i4t |L Mi tL*_c @?_ _i?i B @t |i ThLM@M*|) |@| L?i 4Lhi @U|L? ** LUUh 6Lh i@U @U|L? uLh4@| |ihi i t| @ ?^i &|T*i EK c K2 c c K& Lu t)44i|hU ?Uhi@t?} i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it U UL4TL?i?|t @hi _i?i_ @t uL**Lt uLh ti^i?|@* 6 @U|L?tG K&3, E% ' B , .ifE&n mfE&3, ' %j n

,S 3 'f

B E B.ifE&3,nn mfE&3, ' %j

uLh , ' c c & c

@?_ K& E% ' .ifE&n mfE& ' %j

uLh , ' f

2 uLh ti^i?|@* 5 @U|L?tG K&3, E% ' B , .ifE&n mfE&3,n ' %j n

,S 3 'f

B E B.ifE&3,nn mfE&3,n ' %j

uLh , ' c c & c

@?_ K& E% ' .ifE&n mfE&n ' %j

uLh , ' f

hLLuG 5ii |i TTi?_ W| @TTi@ht uhL4 |i @MLi ThLTLt|L? |@| uLh B 5 Ef( @?_ uLh | &c |i i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it uLh ML| @U|L? uLh4@|t @hi Thi t|h@|i}it |@| ii? L| @** TLttM*i L|UL4itG @| TihL_ |c |i i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) t @? @ih@}i Lu |i E& | hi4@??} i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}it i? B ' i}|i_ M) |i ThLM@M*|it |@| |ihi ** Mi c 2c E& | 4Lhi |i4t uLh t@*i H

Ai uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? t|@|it |@| uLh @hLt *ii*t Lu ?Uih|@?|)c |i hit*|?} ti ^i?Ui Lu ti**?} ThUit 4@) i|ih Mi @ 4@h|?}@*i i|ih @i @ _iU*??} |hi?_ hLTLt|L? 2G 6Lh ML| 6 @?_ 5 @U|L? uLh4@|t @?_ | B i^@* |L |i ThLM@M*|) |@| L?i 4Lhi @U|L? ** LUUhG |i ti^i?Ui Lu i TiU|i_ ThUit t @ 4@h|?}@*i i? B 'c E`iMih EbH .iK&3, EfE&3, j ' .iK&3,3 EfE&3,3 j 2 |i ti^i?Ui Lu i TiU|i_ ThUit t _iU*??} uLh @?) B 5 Ef( G .iK&3, EfE&3, j .iK&3,3 EfE&3,3 j hLLuG 5ii |i TTi?_

e

Ai ti**ih
UL?ti^i?Ui Lu hLTLt|L? t |@| |i ?UL?_|L?@* i TiU|@|L? Lu K, E Ei |i i @?|i i TiU|i_ ti**?} ThUi Lu |i , | |i4 t _i?|U@* uLh ML| @U|L? uLh4@|t `i @hi |ihiuLhi @M*i |L i |i?_ `iMih
|'

At u@h | @t Mii? tL? |@| |i Thiti?Ui Lu ?Uih|@?|) @ML| |i @U|@* ?4Mih Lu |i4t ? ti@*i_ M_ @U|L? uLh4@|t h@tit |i i TiU|i_ ThUi Lu |i ht| E& L?it u |ihi @hi i @U|*) & |i4t T| T uLh t@*i W| @t |t 4T*U|*) @tt4i_ |@| |i @U|@* |L|@* tTT*) Ei?UiuLh| _i?L|i_ M) &W @t i^@* |L & tL |@| |i ?Uih|@?|) ui@|hi Lu |iti b

@U|L?t ?@h@M*) Lh!i_ ? u@Lh Lu |i ti**ih
e

Ai ?L UL44|4i?|< U@ti

W| ** Mi @tt4i_ |@| |i ti**ih !?Lt |i @U|@* tTT*) &W @?_ tit |t ?uLh4@|L? ? @ 4)LTU @) |L ?Uhi@ti t i TiU|i_ hii?i W| ** |i? Mi tL? L |i ti**ih
&[ W 3 |'

+

B &3 .ifE&n j n

& 3 [ |'

, B | E B.ifE|n j

u &W & c Lh {B E&W ' &W .ifE&W n j

&[ W 3 '

+

B &3 .ifE&n j n

& 3 [ |'

, B | E B.ifE|n j

.ifE&n j u &W ' & W? ML| i^@|L?tc &W .ifE&W n j t|@?_t uLh |i i TiU|i_ hii?i i? B ' *i |i uL**L?} |ih4t hiThiti?| |i i TiU|i_ hii?i i? B 5 Ef( ? i|ih U@ti Bi? @ ti| Lu T@h@4i|iht ?c &c s E @?_ Bc | t TLttM*i |L _i?i tL4i ?|i}ih & tU |@| {B E&W t TLt|i uLh &W & E? U U@ti |i ti**ih Thiuiht |L hii@* |i @U|@* tTT*) Lh ?i}@|i uLh &W & EtL |@| i Thiuiht |L UL?Ui@* | Oi?Uic TL? t _iUtL? |L UL?Ui@* &W c M__iht

f

** h@|L?@**) ?uih @ 4?44 TLttM*i ?4Mih & Lu |i4t |L Mi tL*_ @?_ ULhhitTL?_?}*) T_@|i |ih i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it ? |i L|ih @?_c t?Ui |i ThLM@M*|) |@| L?i 4Lhi t@*i 4@) LUUh @t Mii? !iT| UL?t|@?| uLh i@U hL?_ | &c M__iht< T_@|?} ThLUitt ** L?*) @giU| |ih t|h@|i}it @?_ ?L| Eg O@?} _i|ih4?i_ tU @ &c M)iht ** |t M_ @t u |i) ihi thi |@| |ihi ** Mi @| *i@t| & |i4t T| uLh t@*i Ai i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it uLh |t ?i i?hL?4i?| @hi _i?i_ @t ? hLTLt|L? E| B ' uLh TihL_t c c & @?_ |i hit*|?} ti^i?Ui Lu i TiU|i_ ThUit t tL? |L Mi !?!i_< @| |i & | TihL_G | t UL?t|@?| uLh TihL_t |L & @?_ | @t @ _L?@h_ _hu| uLh TihL_t E& n |L & MLt*) u & ' &c |i ti**ih
frxog dovr dvvxph wkdw wkh vhoohu iruhvhhv elgghuv* lqihuhqfhv dqg frqvhtxhqwo| zlwkkrogv lqirupdwlrq

derxw wkh dfwxdo vxsso| iru ydoxhv ri n vpdoohu wkdq n1 Dv wklv zrxog lqyroyh ixuwkhu cfrpprq nqrzohgjh* dvvxpswlrqv/ vxfk dowhuqdwlyh kdv ehhq glvfdughg iurp wkh dqdo|vlv1 Dqrwkhu srvvlelolw| zrxog eh iru wkh vhoohu wr uhylvh klv lqlwldo ghflvlrq wr frqfhdo n lq rughu wr dyrlg orvvhv1 Wklv zrxog reylrxvo| ohdg ex|huv wr jxhvv wkh h{dfw qxpehu ri lwhpv wr eh dxfwlrqhg1

?ih ?uLh4@|L? @ML| &W tL |@| i 4@) t|** i|ih ?Uh @ *Ltt Lh hi@*3i @ }@? At t t44@h3i_ ? |i uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? hLTLt|L? eG Ai ti**ih
? i @4T*i

tt4i |i uL**L?} ti| Lu T@h@4i|ihtG Aihi @hi 2f M__iht E? ' 2fc f _i?|U@* |i4t |L Mi @U|L?i_ E& ' f @?_ M__iht @*it @hi _h@? uhL4 @ ?uLh4 _t|hM|L? L? dfcffo LhhiU| Mi*iutG B ' BW A@M*i hiTLh|t |i @*it Lu {E&W i? EBc BW ' EfDc fDc |i i TiU|i_ ThUit i? &W ' & Ei .i j @?_ |Lti hit*|?} uhL4 |i ti**ih
A@M*i G B@?t @?_ wLttit i? B ' BW ' fD nW 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; < 43

S +w @ nW , 318 3158 31458 313958 3136458 31348958 3133:;46 31336<39 31334<86 31334<86 4

HU+nW ,@ 78157 751;9 63169 4<138 44149 9158 616< 41:< 31<5 31<6 4941<6

HiS jK ;81:5 ;31<: :9156 :4183 991;5 95153 8:1:7 8618: 83133 7:195

fD +nW , 71:8 71:6 0313: 0<199 057143 076177 09:1;8 0<:194 0466165 04:914;

HiS jS :9156 :9156 :9156 :4183 991;5 95153 8:1:7 8618: 83133 7:195

fD +nW , 47158 4;1<: 4714: 718; 0<1;9 05<153 086194 0;616: 044<13< 04941<7

HU +nW ,_ 78157 751;9 5;18< 4;1:9 4417: 91:4 61;3 5144 4148 4158 4941<6

= Orqj uxq h{shfwhg uhyhqxh zkhq N @ n dqg wkh vhoohu uhyhdov n + @ 3=8,1 HU+n ,@n Hi[+n .4, j=S +w @n , e = H{shfwhg vhoolqj sulfh li n @n dqg @ 3=8 f = Xsgdwhg h{shfwhg vhoolqj sulfh li wkh vhoohu frqfhdov n dqg @ 3=8 g = Orqj uxq h{shfwhg uhyhqxh zkhq N @ n dqg wkh vhoohu uhyhdov vwudwhjlfdoo| n 1 Li 3=8 +n , A 3/ zh kdyh HUx +n ,@HU+n , Sn HiSx jl Li 3=8 +n , ? 3/ zh kdyh HUx +n ,@S +w @ n , l@4 d

T|4t|U Mi*iutG B : BW )iht @hi @tt4i_ ihi |L Mi 4Lhi LT|4t|U |@? |i ti**ih EL @t TihuiU| ?uLh4@|L? @ML| |i h@?_L4?itt Lu tTT*) A@M*i 2 hiTLh|t |i U@ti ihi EBc BW ' Ef.c fD *|L} {fD E&W ? A@M*i ?_Uit |i ti**ih |L UL?Ui@* &W u &W 2c i ** ?L| _L tL Oi ** hii@* &W u &W D ? Lh_ih |L hi4@? UL?tt|i?| | M)iht< ?uihi?Uit U @hi M@ti_ L? B E|t t ?_Ui_ M) {f. E&W ? A@M*i 2 W? |t ti||?}c |i M__iht< LT|4t|U Mi*iu 4i@?t |@| |i ti**ih U@??L| |@!i u** @_@?|@}i Lu t L? ?ih ?uLh4@|L? BW A@M*i 2 uh|ih4Lhi hii@*t |@| |@| {f. E&W f uLh &W S @?_ {f. E&W f uLh &W b tL |@| M) UL?Ui@*?} &W c |i ti**ih ** ?Uh @ *Ltt u S &W H @?_ hi@*3i @ }@? u &W t i^@* |L b Lh f W? |i *L?} h? Liihc |t t|h@|i}U TL*U) L*_ )i*_ 4 @ *Lih i TiU|i_ hii?i |@? u i @*@)t hii@*i_ |i @@*@M*i tTT*) |L Mi @U|L?i_

A@M*i 2G B@?t @?_ wLttit i? B : BW Q EB ' f.c BW ' fD Q nW 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; < 43 e f

S +w @ nW , 318 3158 31458 313958 3136458 31348958 3133:;46 31336<39 31334<86 31334<86 4

HU+nW , 78157 751;9 63169 4<138 44149 9158 616< 41:< 31<5 31<6 4941<6

HiS jK :<1;4 :8157 :31:9 9916< 9514; 8;155 87193 8417; 7<138 7:195

f. +nW , 43199 4916: 4:137 45189 51:9 045194 0661;; 094188 0<9164 046<14:

HiS jS 8;155 8;155 8;155 8;155 8;155 8;155 87193 8417; 7<138 7:195

f. +nW , 65158 871<; 9;14< :41;: 99136 83199 5<16< 41:5 066137 0:81<3

HU +nW , 78157 751;9 63169 4<138 44149 8179 6149 41:; 31<< 413; 494145

= H{shfwhg vhoolqj sulfh li n @n dqg @ 3=: = Xsgdwhg h{shfwhg vhoolqj sulfh li wkh vhoohu frqfhdov n dqg @ 3=:

A@M*i G B@?t @?_ wLttit i? B BW Q EB ' f c BW ' fD Q nW 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; < 43 e f

S +w @ nW , 318 3158 31458 313958 3136458 31348958 3133:;46 31336<39 31334<86 31334<86 4

HU+nW , 78157 751;9 63169 4<138 44149 9158 616< 41:< 31<5 31<6 4941<6

HiS jK ;;177 ;619: :;1<4 :7148 9<16< 97197 8<1<4 8815< 831<8 7:194

f +nW , 5137 0319; 0;149 053174 06:175 08<154 0;81:< 044:15: 04861<7 04<91:<

HiS jS ;619: ;619: :;1<4 :7148 9<16< 97197 8<1<4 8815< 831<8 7:194

f +nW , 91;3 713; 06173 048198 065199 087178 0;4136 0445184 047<14: 04<5136

= H{shfwhg vhoolqj sulfh li n @n dqg @ 3=6 = Xsgdwhg h{shfwhg vhoolqj sulfh li wkh vhoohu frqfhdov n dqg @ 3=6

e

HU +nW , 78157 741;7 631:; 53136 451;4 :14 7135 5156 4154 4164 4981<6

itt4t|U Mi*iutG B BW W? A@M*i c | t @tt4i_ |@| M)iht @i @ Titt4t|U Mi*iu @ML| BW G EBc BW ' Ef c fD Ai @h}4i?| t t4*@h |L |i L?i t| }i? i UiT| |@| |i ti**ih ** ?Lc @UULh_?} |L {f E&W c UL?Ui@* &W 2 *i i L*_ @i Thiuihhi_ |L hii@* | L?*) uLh &W E@UULh_?} |L {fD E&W ? A@M*i ) UL4T@h?} |i hi@*3@|L?t Lu g uLh U {f E&W @?_ {f E&W MiUL4i ?i}@|ic i tii |@| |i ti**ih
uvw prphqwv ri wkh rughu vwdwlvwlfv iru wkh orjqrupdo glvwulexwlrqv zhuh wdnhq iurp Jxswd/ Pf0

Grqdog dqg Jdoduqhdx +4<:7,1

D

|L Mi tL*_c |i ti**ih
e2

Ai UL44|4i?|< U@ti

+@|ih |@? UL?Ui@*?} t|h@|i}U@**)|i @U|@* tTT*) T| T uLh t@*ic |i ti**ih UL*_ @*tL UL44| 4ti*u |L Mi ?@@hi Lu |i tTT*) @@*@M*i uLh t@*i Ai i TiU|i_ hii?i uhL4 @ }i? tittL? L*_ |i? _iTi?_ i U*ti*) L? |i hi@*3@|L? Lu gG {B E&W 4@) i|ih Mi ?i}@|i EuLh &W & Lh TLt|i EuLh &W & Wu B ' BW c |i ti**ih
S

|@| t B BW EB : BW c | uL**Lt |@| |i ti**ih L*_ Mi Mi||ih Lg ELhti Lg UL44||?} 4ti*u |L Mi ?@@hi Lu |i @@*@M*i tTT*) |L Mi Lgihi_ uLh t@*i ? @ }i? tittL? At t t|@|i_ ? |i uL**L?} ThLTLt|L? hLTLt|L? DG `i? UL4T@hi_ |L |i tTT*) Uih|@?|) U@ti EB ' c |i ti**ih
D

L?U*tL?

W? |t T@Tih | @t tL? |@| i? ht!?i|h@* M__iht T@h|UT@|i ? @ ti^i?Ui Lu 6 Lh 5 @U|L?t | ?Uih|@? tTT*)c @ _iU*??} |hi?_ Lu ThUit 4@) hit*|t 5)44i|hU i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it ihi _ihi_ uLh ML| @U|L? uLh4@|t W| @t LMtihi_ |@| uLh @?) }i? TihL_c |i LT|4@* M_ t @? @ih@}i Lu |i hi4@??} i^*Mh4 M_t |@| L*_ Mi tM4||i_ ? |i tTT*) Uih|@?|) uh@4iLh!c i}|i_ M) |i ThLM@M*|it |@| |iti hi4@??} |i4t ** ?_ii_ Mi Lgihi_ uLh t@*i W| @t @*tL tL? |@| |i ti**ih
.

i@h*ih ThL|t @hi 4Lhi @*i_ |@? *@|ih L?itc M__iht t@_i |ih M_t *itt |@? u |i) ihi ?_gihi?| @ML| |i |4?} Lu |ih ii?|@* ThL| *|L} ML| |i ?Uih|@? tTT*) @?_ _tUL?|?} @tt4T|L?t @hi t4*@h ? |ih4t Lu |ih 4T@U| L? |i uLh4@|L? Lu ThUit |L |i UL?t|@?| @MtL*|i ht! @ihtL? @tt4T |L?c |iti |L UL?UiT|t hi4@? u?_@4i?|@**) _gihi?| Ai *@||ih t ?_ii_ @ |*|@h@? |LL* i Thitt?} |i M)iht< hi*U|@?Uic uLh @ }i? TihL_c |L T*@) @ *L||ih) Lti Uih|@?|) i^@*i?| U@? Mi LM|@?i_ L? T@)4i?| Lu @ ht! Thi44 *i |i uLh4ih @tt4T|L?t U@h@U|ih3ic ? |t ti^i?|@* ti||?}c @ |4i u@U|Lh U Uhi@|it @ *?! Mi|ii? TihL_t 6?@**)c @t |i @MLi hit*|t L*_ L?*) u |i @U|@* ?4Mih Lu |i4t |L Mi @U|L?i_ t i^@* |L @| M__iht @tt4i |L Mi |i 4@ 44 TLttM*i ?4Mih Lu |i4t &c |L U@tit ihi |i @U|@* tTT*) UL*_ Mi *itt |@? & ihi i @4?i_ Ai ht| U@ti @tt4i_ |i ti**ih |L !?L |i @@*@M*i tTT*) @?_ |L @_LT| @ 4)LTU t|h@| i}) |L@h_t |i hi*i@ti Lh |L*_?} Lu t ?uLh4@|L? ? Lh_ih |L ?Uhi@ti t i TiU|i_ hii?i W| @t tL? |@| TL? t _iUtL? |L UL?Ui@* |i @@*@M*i tTT*)c u M__iht @hi i?_Li_ | @ h@|L?@* ?uihi?Ui ThLUittc |ih T_@|i_ t|h@|i}it 4@) )i*_ |L |i ti**ih @ *Lih i TiU|i_ hii?i |@? |@| U i ?|@**) i TiU|i_ Aiti T_@|i_ t|h@|i}it @hi _i|ih4?i_ @?_ |i hit*|?} ti^i?Ui Lu i TiU|i_ ThUit t tL? |L Mi !?!i_G | 4@) ht| Mi UL?t|@?| uLh @ }i? ?4Mih Lu TihL_t @?_ @i @ _iU*??} _hu| uLh |i hi4@??} L?it L?t_ih@|L? @t @*tL }i? |L t|@|L?t ihi M)iht @i @ hL?} Mi*iu @ML| |i @U|@* h@?_L4?itt Lu tTT*) @?_ |i 4T@U| Lu tU @ hL?} Mi*iu L? |i ti**ih
H

|i tTT*) Uih|@?|) uh@4iLh!c ?Uhi@tic _iUhi@ti Lh *i@i ?@giU|i_ t *L?} h? i TiU|i_ hii?i At hit*| t LM|@?i_ M) @tt4?} |@| |i t@4i ti^i?Ui Lu @U|L?t t hiTi@|i_ Lih |4i | |i t@4i ?4Mih Lu T@h|UT@?|t _h@?} |ih Th@|i?_iTi?_i?| @*it uhL4 |i t@4i _t|hM|L? At @tt4T|L? t T@h|U*@h*) hi*i@?| uLh 4@h!i|t U @hi Lh}@?3i_ L? @ hi}*@h M@tt | |i t@4i ti| Lu T@h|UT@?|tc tU @t @U|L?t uLh Tiht@M*i }LL_t 6?@**)c @t tU @ UL44|4i?| uLh |i ti**ih @t Mii? i4ThU@**) LMtihi_ ? tL4i t @U|L?tc |t hit*| 4@) ThL_i tL4i ?t}|t ?|L |i i t|i?Ui Lu tU Th@U|Ui

b

TTi?_

hLLu Lu hLTLt|L? G Ai ThLLu U@t|t |i uL**L?} wi44@c ThLi_ ? w@gL?| @?_ AhL*i Ebb c T2 wi44@ G L?t_ih @ |Ui UL?|?Lt*) _gihi?|@M*i u?U|L? Eoc %c KEo $ ? ihi KE t @ UL?|?Lt 4L?L|L?U u?U|L? Lu o Wu Y Eoc %c KEomo'% ' f |i? tUi?| UL?_|L?t @hi @*tL t@|ti_G o ' % hiThiti?| @ }*LM@* LT|44 uLh Ec c AL _i|ih4?i |i t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}itc | t UL?i?i?| |L UL?t_ih |i t|@?_TL?| Lu @ }i? M)ih Lti @*i t % @?_ L _i?it t : t2 : : t?3 @t |i Lh_ih t|@|t|Ut Lu |i E? L|ih @*it t @** @*it @hi ?_iTi?_i?|*) @?_ _i?|U@*) _h@? uhL4 @ ?L? _i}i?ih@|i_ _t|hM|L? 8 E _i?i_ L? ?n c |i _t|hM|L? Lu t, }i? |i hi@*3@|L? Lu t,3 ' +,3 @?_ |t _i?t|) @hi _i?i_ @t ?3, 8 El E? ,8 El?3,3 s El 8t, Elm+,3 ' @?_ st, Elm+,3 ' 8 E+,3 8 E+,3 ?3, | 8t| Em+ c +2 c c +|3 ' 8t| Em+|3 t u@h @t ?L|@|L? t UL?Uih?i_c |i t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}) @| TihL_ | }i? |i LMtihi_ hi@*3@|L?t Lu t c t2 c c t|3 t _i?L|i_ M) K| Ec + c c +|3 @?_ |i i ThittL? Yo Eoc %mo'% ** t|@?_ uLh |i ht| _ih@|i Lu Eoc % | hitTiU| |L o 6Lh i@U @U|L? uLh4@|c |i ThLLu ThLUii_t ? |L t|iTt 6L**L?} *}hL4 @?_ `iMih EbH2Mc | t ht| tL? |@| ? @?) }i? TihL_ |c @ M__ih U@? _L ?L Mi||ih |i? |L M_ K @? ?Uhi@t?} u?U|L? Lu 4?i%c +|3 j At t _L?i hiUhti*) M) t|@h|?} uhL4 |i *@t| @U|L? TihL_ @?_ M) t?} @ |)TU@* tM}@4i TihuiU|L? @h}4i?|G @| i@U TihL_ |c @ M__ih ** it|4@|i t ii?|@* }@? Lh *Ltt uhL4 _i@|?} uhL4 |i t)44i|hU i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) }i? |@| @** L|ih M__iht @_LT| |i i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) @?_ |@| i ** M_ @| i^*Mh4 ? @** tMti^i?| TihL_t Ai i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it @hi |i? _i|ih4?i_ ? @ tiUL?_ t|iT 2f

5i^i?|@* 6 @U|L?t 5L*_ |i &| @U|L? TihL_ LUUhc @ M__ih
Lh i^@*i?|*) & Eo& c %

8 Eo& ' d% K& Eo& c + c c +&3 o 8 E+&3

?3&

@?_ u o& : +&3 c & Eo& c % ' d% K& Eo& c + c c +&3 o Ai ht| Lh_ih UL?_|L? hi^hit |@| Yo& & Eo& c %o '% ' f 6hL4 wi44@ c t?Ui K& E t & t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? M__iht< @*itc |t ?iUitt@h) UL?_|L? t @*tL tUi?| 6Lh o& +&3 c | |t uL**Lt |@| Yo& K& Eo& c + c c +&3 8 Eo& ?3& nd% K& Eo& c + c c +&3 oE? &8 Eo& ?3&3 sEo& o '% ' f & U )i*_t Yo& K& E%c + c c +&3 ' d% K& E%c + c c +&3 oE? &

s E% 8 E%

u % +&3 c

@?_ Yo& K& E%c + c c +&3 ' f

u % : +&3

At t @ ht|Lh_ih _gihi?|@* i^@|L? U @t uLh ML?_@h) UL?_|L? KEfc ' f 6h |ih4Lhic t?Ui Yo& K& E%c + c c +&3 t ?_iTi?_i?| uhL4 + c c +&3 uLh % +&3 c K& E%c + c c +&3 t @U|@**) i^@* |L K& E% ? |i L|ih @?_c uLh % : +&3 c K& E%c + c c +&3 ' K& E+&3 Ai *@t| TihL_ i^*Mh4 t|h@|i}) t |t @ u?U|L? _i?i_ M) K& E4?i%c +&3 j 2

6Lh TihL_t | ' c c & c |i M__ih
&3 c %

'

] o&3 f

d% K&3 Eo&3 c + c c +&32 ost&3 Ekm+&32 _k

nB

] +&32 o&3

d% K& E4?i%c kjost&3 Ekm+&32 _k

u o&3 +&32 c @?_ &3 Eo&3 c % ' d% K&3 Eo&3 c + c c +&32 o u o&3 : +&32 `i? o&3 +&32 c |i tiUL?_ *?i hiThiti?|t |i ThL| @ M__ih i TiU|t uLh |i &| TihL_ }i? |@| i __ ?L| ? |i ThiLt @U|L? Eihi i M_ @t u t @*i @t o&3 +&32 @?_ |@| i ** ti t LT|4@* t|h@|i}) ? |i & | @U|L? ? |i L|ih @?_c M) M__?} ? |i ?i ||L*@t| TihL_ @t u t @*i @t o&3 : +&32 c |@| M__ih ** ? | ThLM@M*|) L?i t?Ui |i M__?} t|h@|i}it @hi @tt4i_ |L Mi t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} ? M__iht< @*it t uLh |i *@t| TihL_c |i 4@ 4t@|L? Lu |i M__ih
E &3 '%

'f

t ?L|i_ M) Uuii @?_ V?Ui?| Ebb c E t _gihi?| _iTi?_?} L? i|ih % : o&3 Lh % o&3 M| UL?ih}it |L |i t@4i @*i @t o&3 @TThL@Uit % ) ti||?} E i^@* |L f @| % ' o&3 c |i uL**L?} _gihi?|@* i^@|L? t LM|@?i_

22

Yo&3 K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' d% K&3 E%c + c c +&32 oE? & n Bd% K& E%oE? & n

s E% 8 E%

s E% 8 E%

u % +&32 c @?_ Yo&3 K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' f u % : +&32 6hL4 ihic | uL**Lt |@| |i i^*Mh4 M__?} u?U|L? @| |i E&| @U|L? TihL_ t ?_iTi?_i?| uhL4 + c c +&3 u % +&32 c tL |@| K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' K&3 E% @?_ |@| K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' K&3 E+&32 u % : +&32 Ai i^*Mh4 M__?} u?U|L? uLh |i E& | @U|L? TihL_ t |t _i?i_ @t K&3 E4?i%c +&32 j Ai t@4i ThLUi_hi U@? Mi ti_ |L _i?i i^*Mh4 M__?} u?U|L?t uLh |i E& 2 hi4@??} TihL_t | |i L|ti| Lu |i ti^i?Uic +f t @tt4i_ |L Mi i^@* |L ??|) ELh |L |i i |hi44 Lu |i tTTLh| Lu 8 E | |i @U|L? TihL_ |c |i LT|4@* M__?} t|h@|i}) t |t _i?i_ @t K| E4?i%c +|3 j t |i M__?} t|h@|i}it @hi @** ?Uhi@t?} ? @ M)ih
2

@?_ uLh |i ?i ||L*@t| @U|L?

+

%

?3& & ] % 8 E| K&3 E% ' B E? & n % _| 8 E% f &, ] % 8 E| ?3&n _| E? & % 8 E% f %

+

?3& , ] % 8 E| nE B % _| 8 E% f Lh i^@*i?|*) K&3 E% ' B.ifE&n mfE&3 ' %j n E B.ifE& mfE&3 ' %j K&32 c K&3 c c K @hi LM|@?i_ ? @ t4*@h @)

5i^i?|@* 5 @U|L?t Bi? |@| |i ThUi T@)i_ M) |i }it| M__ih t i^@* |L |i tiUL?_ }it| M_c |i _L4?@?| t|h@|i}) _i?i_ uLh L?itL| @U|L?t Ei |L tM4| L?i
nB

+] +&32 o&3

] % f

st&3 E1m+&32 _1

d% 1ost& E1m+&3 ' %_1

u o&3 +&32 c @?_ &3 Eo&3 c % ' d% K&3 Eo&3 c + c c +&32 o u o&3 : +&32

2e

`i? o&3 +&32 c |i ht| *?i i Thittit @ M__ih
d% K&3 Eo&3 c + c c +&32 oE? & n 8 Eo&3 ?3& sEo&3 B E? & n 8 Eo&3 ?3& s Eo&3

] % f

E2

E? &8 E1?3&3 s E1 d% 1o _1 8 E%?3&

o&3 '%

'f

Oihi @}@?c E2 t _gihi?| i|ih % : o&3 Lh % o&3 @?_ UL?ih}it |L |i t@4i @*i @t o&3 @TThL@Uit uhL4 %c tL |@| ti||?} E2 i^@* |L f @| % ' o&3 )i*_t |i uL**L?} ti| Lu i^@|L?t %

?3& & ] % 8 E1 K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' E B% n B % _1 8 E% f

u % +&32 c

@?_ Yo&3 K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' f

u % : +&32

Mtihi |@| |i i^*Mh4 M__?} u?U|L? @| |i E& | @U|L? TihL_ _iTi?_t L?*) L? % u % +&32 c tL |@| K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' K&3 E% @?_ |@| K&3 E%c + c c +&32 ' K&3 E+&32 u % : +&32 Ai i^*Mh4 M__?} u?U|L? uLh |i E& | @U|L? TihL_ t |t _i?i_ @t K&3 E4?i%c +&32 j W| U@? t4*@h*) Mi tL? |@| ? i@U TihL_ |c @ M__ih U@? _L ?L Mi||ih |@? |L M_ K| E4?i%c +|3 j U hiih|t Q M) ti Lu |i u@U| |@| M__?} t|h@|i}it @hi ?Uhi@t?} u?U|L?t Lu @*it @?_ ? UL??U|L? | _i??} +f @t ??|) Lh @t |i i |hi44 Lu |i tTTLh| Lu 8 E Q |L M_ K| E% Ai *@||ih ** |t |@!i |i uL**L?} i ThittL?t

2D

K& E% ' % Lh i^@*i?|*)

K& E% ' . fE&n mfE&n ' %

@?_ K&3 E% ' B.ifE&n mfE& ' %j n E B.ifE&n mfE&n ' %j K&32 c K&3 c c K @hi LM|@?i_ ? @ t4*@h @) t |i uL**L?} ThLLut }L @*L?} |i t@4i *?it uLh ML| @U|L? uLh4@|tc L?*) |Lti uLh |i 6 @U|L? ti||?} @hi ThL_i_

2S

hLLu Lu hLTLt|L? 2G 6Lh B ' c .iK&3, EfE&3, mK&3,3 EfE&3,3 ' qj / .i.ifE&n mfE&3, jmK3 &3,3 Eq ' fE&3,3 j 3 / .i.ifE&n mfE&3, jmK3 &3,3 Eq ' fE&3,3 j / .ifE&n mK&3,3 Eq ' fE&3,3 j / K&3,3 EK3 &3,3 Eq ' q

2 6Lh f B c |@!i |i _gihi?Ui Mi|ii? |i i TiU|i_ ThUi Lu |i E& ,| TihL_ Ei |i ?UL?_|L?@* i TiU|i_ M_ LM|@?i_ i? B 5 Efc | |i L?i LM|@?i_ i? B ' At )i*_tc # B , .ifE&n j n Lh i^@*i?|*)c E B

, 3 [ 'f

, [ 'f

$ B E B.ifE&3,nn j

.ifE&n j

B .ifE&3,nn j .ifE&n j

E

U t TLt|i uLh @?) f , & 5?Ui |i ti^i?Ui Lu i TiU|i_ ThUit @t tL? |L Mi @ 4@h|?}@*i ? |i tTT*) Uih|@?|) U@tic | uL**Lt |@| E t ?Uhi@t?} | , uLh @?) B 5 Efc 6Lh , ' fc E t i^@* |L 3ihL

hLLu Lu hLTLt|L? eG 6ht|c | tL*_ Mi ?L|i_ |@| @|iih |i ti| Lu T@h@4i|iht hi|@?i_ Ei ?c s E @?_ & : c {B E t @*@)t TLt|i @?_ {B E& t @*@)t ?i}@|i 6h|ih4Lhi t?Ui {B E&W t t|hU|*) UL?U@i ? &W c |ihi i t| L?*) L?i hi@* ?4Mih V 5 E( & tU |@| uLh &W Vc |i ti**ih ?Uht @ *Ltt M) |L*_?} ?uLh4@|L? E{B E&W : f @?_ uLh &W : Vc i hi@*3it @ }@? E{B E&W f W? Lh_ih |L @L_ |i ti||?} Lu |iMhi@!?} h*it i? V @t @? ?|i}ih @*i ? E( & U L*_ )i*_ {B EV ' f uLh V ' &W c | t @tt4i_ |@| |i ti**ih hii@*t |i @U|@* tTT*) i? &W ' V NT_@|i_ i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it @?_ hit*|?} |hi?_ Lu ThUit 2.

O@?} _i?i_ @? ?|i}ih & 5 E( & tU |@| {B E& : f @?_ {B E& fc @?_ M) t?} |i ThLLu Lu hLTLt|L? E| B ' uLh TihL_t |L &c |i T_@|i_ i^*Mh4 M__?} t|h@|i}it uLh 6 @U|L?t U@? Mi _i?i_ @t K&3, E% ' B &3& .ifE&n mfE&3, ' %j n

&3S & 3 'f

B E B.ifE&nn mfE&3, ' %j

uLh , ' fc c & c

K&3, E% ' B , .ifE&n mfE&3, ' %j n

,S 3 'f

B E B.ifE&3,nn mfE&3, ' %j

uLh , ' c c & c

@?_ K& E% ' .ifE&n mfE& ' %j ) |@!?} |i ?UL?_|L?@* i TiU|@|L?t Lu |iti i^*Mh4 M_tc | t tii? |@| uLh TihL_t |L &c |i i TiU|i_ ti**?} ThUit ** Mi UL?t|@?| @?_ i^@* |L B

& 3&

.ifE&n j n

&3 & 3 [ 'f

B E B.ifE&nn j

*t| uLh TihL_t E& n |L &W c |i) ** Mi _iUhi@t?} E|t t tii? uhL4 |i tiUL?_ U@ti Lu |i ThLLu Lu hLTLt|L? 2 Ai ti**ih
}i? |i t|hU| UL?U@|) Lu {B E&W ? &W c |ihi t @ ?i V : V tU |@| @ ?i ?|i}ih & & U@? Mi _i?i_ t @ hit*|c u & &W & c |i ti**ih L*_ @i Thiuihhi_ ?L| |L UL?Ui@* &W t?Ui |t )i*_t 4 ?L @ t4@**ih i TiU|i_ hii?i i? UL4T@hi_ |L |i L?i i UL*_ LM|@? M) ?|@**) hii@*?} &W A@| tc {B E&W @t ?|@**) ?i}@|i *i {B E&W t ?L TLt|i ? |i L|ih @?_c u & ' &c {B E&W hi4@?t ?i}@|ic tL |@| |i ti**ih ?Uhi@tit t i TiU|i_ hii?i uhL4 |L*_?} ?uLh4@|L? L? &W 2 uLh B BW c | t !?L? uhL4 hLTLt|L? 2 |@| |i ti**ih
2b

hLLu Lu hLTLt|L? DG W? |i tLh| h? t ? |i ?L?UL44|4i?| uh@4iLh!c |ihi @hi |hii U@tit |L UL?t_ih _iTi?_?} L? M__iht< UL44L? Mi*iu B @ML| |i @U|@* h@?_L4?itt Lu tTT*) BW 5?Ui |ihi @hi ?L LT|L?t uLh |i ti**ih |L ULLti t Mit| ?uLh4@|L? TL*U)c L?i U@? L?*) _i|ih4?i |i L|UL4it Lu g uLh U i hi@*3it @ }@? Lh @ *Ltt Aiti @hi t4*@h |L |Lti _i?i_ ? |i ThLLu Lu hLTLt|L? e W? |i *L?} h? W? Lh_ih |L UL4T@hi |i *L?} h? i TiU|i_ hii?it LM|@?i_ uhL4 |i tTT*) Uih|@?|) @?_ |i tTT*) ?Uih|@?|) i?hL?4i?|tc | tUit |L UL4T@hi @** TLttM*i i TiU|i_ hii?it uLh |i ti**ih i? ML| |i ti**ih @?_ |i M)iht @hi TihuiU|*) ?uLh4i_ @ML| |i @U|@* tTT*)c |@| t & 3

BW

&.ifE&n j n

& 32 [ 'f

BW E BW E n .ifEn2 j

Ee

| @** TLttM*i i TiU|i_ hii?it LM|@?i_ ? |i tTT*) ?Uih|@?|) U@tic |@| t # $ & 32 n &[ 3|3 [ [ BW E BW B &3| .ifE&n j n B E B.ifE|n n j |'

'f

& 3

nBW

'f

+ &32 n # $ , &[ 3|3 [[ & 3| B .ifE&n j n B E B.ifE|n n j n .ifE&n j 'f |'

ED

'f

W| t ?L ihi_ |@| ED i^@*t Ee uLh B ' BW c |@| | t }hi@|ih uLh B BW @?_ t4@**ih uLh B : BW

f

)LJXUHVHOOHU VORQJUXQH[SHFWHGUHYHQXH (difference between "concealing N " and "always revealing N ") 8 7 6 5 4 3 LogN(50;5)

2

LogN(50;10)

1

U[0;100] 0 -1 -2

0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1

%X\HUV %HOLHIG

+iuihi?Uit do ti?ui*|ihc h*i) c bHbc OL @U|L?t Lh! uLh ?i @?_ @h|c aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4U ihtTiU|itc c 2 S d2o ih?@h_|c #@? @?_ #@_ 5ULL?itc bbec ?L|i L? ti^i?|@* @U|L?tc 4ihU@? ,UL?L4U +iic Hec SD SD. d o *@U!c a@?i @?_ #@_ #i i3@c bb2c 5)t|i4@|U ThUi _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? tUUitti @U|L?t @hi ?L @?L4@*)c aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Ut : @?@}i4i?| 5|h@|i})c c Sf.S2H deo @tt@_)c +@*T ahc bS.c U|L?t @?_ U|L?iih?} EN?iht|) Lu @*uLh?@ hittc ih!i*i)

2

dDo ,?}i*MhiU|`}}@?tc +U@h_c bbec 5i^i?|@* @U|L?t Lu t|LU@t|U@**) i^@*i?| LMiU|tc ,UL?L4U wi||ihtc eec H.bf dSo 6h@4c #L?@*_ B @?_ wii 6 5Uh@_ihc b.fc ? i Tih4i?|@* UL4T@htL? Lu ThU?} ? |L @U|L? t)t|i4tc 4ihU@? aLh?@* Lu }hU*|h@* ,UL?L4Utc D2c D2HD e d.o B@*ic W@? w @?_ #L?@*_ O@tUc bbec L||L4t?} @?_ _iU*??} ThUit ? ti ^i?|@* @U|L?tc B@4it @?_ ,UL?L4U i@Lhc .c H dHo BT|@c 5@?| 5c B@h) U#L?@*_ @?_ #@?i W B@*@h?i@c b.ec L4i?|tc ThL_U| 4L4i?|t @?_ TihUi?|@}i TL?|t Lu |i Lh_ih t|@|t|Ut uhL4 |i *L}?Lh4@* _t|hM|L? uLh t@4T*it Lu t3i |i?|) @?_ *ittc 5@?!)7@G Ai W?_@? aLh?@* Lu 5|@|t|Utc Sc 5ihit c 2 f2Sf dbo w@gL?|c ai@?a@U^it @?_ ai@? AhL*ic bb c |iLh) Lu ThLUhi4i?| @?_ hi}*@|L? EWA hitt dfo @||itc 5|ii?c bH.c L4T@h?} @U|L?t uLh ht! @ihti M)ihtG M)ih

dDo 5?!i*tc aihLi?c bbc *|?|c 4*|TihL_ @U|L?tc tTT*) ?Uih|@?|)c @?_ |i iUi?U) Lu t)44i|hU i^*Mh@c ?TM*ti_ 4@?tUhT|c h?Ui|L? N?iht|) dSo VU!hi)c `**@4c bSc L?|ihtTiU*@|L?c @U|L?tc @?_ UL4Ti||i ti@*i_ |i?_ihtc aLh?@* Lu 6?@?Uic Sc H . d.o `iMihc +LMih| ac bH c *|T*iLMiU| @U|L?tc ?G +U@h_ ,?}i*MhiU|`}}@?tc @h|? 5M! @?_ +LMih| 5|@h!c i_tc U|L?tc __?} @?_ L?|h@U|?}G Ntit @?_ AiLh) Ei vLh! N?iht|) hitt SDb

e