!"#   $ % &' # ( )*  # ( +

 


, $ - .+ % """ $ # (" /0 & ' # ( $.+*  # ( +

1 2 34 5 1 64 7 89:;< => 8@:=@:8?B D:;; 9 ? <> 8@:=@:8? => @P < 8N @P < H8;< 8I = ? <> 8@:=@:?> =>
    V     

eafZY \ `l\ \_`Z`Z\e `l]` ded][[g ]fZe\ Z_ `lXe\ ege`\b e ]_i `l\_ elXk lXk `l\g Z_`\f]a` r y_ `lZe b X i\[ j W XYZ[\ ]^\_` aXb cd`Z_^ Ze ]_ Z_af\]eZ_^[g Zb c Xfh ]^\_`e ]f\ ]d`X_Xb Xde j Z_ `l\ e\_e\ `l ]` `l\g iX `]_` c]f]iZ^b j k lZal cf\e\_`e Z_`\f\e`Z_^ _\k e\adh _X` _\\i `X aX_`]a` `l\Zf Xk _\fe ]s`\f `l\g ]f\ f\h fZ`g al][[\_^\e m6l\ee j noopq r 1 b X_^ `l\e\ ]f\ `l\ [\]e\i — `l\g a]ffg ][^XfZ`lb e ]_i fd[\e `l]` ][[Xk cfX`\a`ZX_ Xs lXe`e ]^]Z_e` b ][ZaZXd e ]^\_`e ]_i `l\ `l\b `X ]a` X_ `l\Zf Xk _\f ˜e Y \l ][s r cfX`\a`ZX_ Xs ]^\_`e ]^]Z_e` b ][ZaZXde lXe`e r t lZ[\ b ]_g eX[d`ZX_e l]u\ ][f\]ig Y \\_ cfXc Xe\i ]_i Zb h  ™‹ ‹’““‹• c[\b \_`\i sXf cfX`\a`Z_^ lXe`e `l ]` \v\ad`\ ]^\_`e j Z` ]cc \]fe `X Y \ b Xf\ iZw ad[` `X x_i cf]a`Za][ eXh t\ i\][ k Z`l `lf\\ iZš \f\_` \_`Z`Z\e — ]^\_`e ˜ Xk _h \fe j `l\ ]^\_`e `l\b e\[u\e j ]_i ]^\_` c[]a\e r [d`ZX_e `X `l\ cfXY[\b Xs cfX`\a`Z_^ ]^\_`e r 3c \aZ][[g Xs Z_`\f\e` Ze `l\ d e\ Xs ]^\_`e Z_ \[\ah  › ’‹Ž œ Z` Ze `l\ \_`Z`g k lZal YdZ[ie ]_i aX_x^df\e `fX_Za aXb b \fa\ e\``Z_^e j Z_ k lZal de\fe f\[\]e\ `l\ ]^\_`e ]_i ec \aZx \e `l\Zf b ZeeZX_ j f\[\]eZ_^ ]d`X_Xb Xde ]^\_`e `X fX]b ]fXd_i uZf`d][ e`Xf\e `l\b X_ `l\ _\`kXfz `X ]aaXb c[Zel `l\Zf  XY r ]_i x_ i i\eZf\i cfX ida`e ]` ]aa\c`]Y[\ cfZa\e r y_ `l\e\ \_uZfX_b \_`e Z` Ze i\eZf]Y[\ `X ]d`Xb ]`\ ‘‹’“• œ ]f\ b XYZ[\ cZ\a\e Xs aX i\ `l]` k Z[[ \v\h `l\ cdfal]eZ_^ cfX a\ee j ][[Xk Z_^ ]^\_`e `X c \fh ad`\ eXb \ ]a`ZX_ X_ Y \l ][s Xs `l\Zf Xk _\fe r ys sXfb `]eze edal ]e e\[\a`ZX_ Xs Z`\b e j _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Xs ]_ ]^\_` eZ^_ e ]_ ]^f\\b \_` j Z`e Xk _\f k Z[[ Y \ cfZa\e ]_i X`l\f aX_ iZ`ZX_e j ]_i ZeedZ_^ ]_ i eZ^_h Y Xd_i Yg Z`e `\fb e r Z_^ c ]gb \_` Xfi\fe r { ]`df][[gj `lZe c Xe\e ] e\adfZ`g `lf\]` `X `l\ cfZu]`\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ a]ffZ\i Yg edal ‘‹’“ ž ŒŸ ‹• œ ]_ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze ] e\fu\f ]cc[Zh a]`ZX_ k l\f\ ]^\_`e a]_ YZ_i `X ]_i \v\ad`\ ]d`X_Xb Xde ]^\_`e r 4f]iZ`ZX_ ][ cfXvg eZ^_ ]`df\e `l\Zf aX i\ r 4 l\ c[]a\ b ]g Y \ ]_ ]^\_`hY]e\i mW ]b Y X \` ][rj noo|q cfXuZi\ ] c]f`Z][ eX[d`ZX_ `X b ]fz\`c[]a\ j eXb \ \_`fg c XZ_` `X ] iZe`fZYd`\i `lZe cfXY[\b ]_i `l\ de\ Xs `fd e`\i \_uZfX_b \_`e i]`]Y]e\ j \`a r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze _X` `fde`\i m}\\ ]_i 4g^]f j noo~q cfXb Ze\e Z_`\f\e`Z_^ cf]a`Zh Yg `l\ Xk _\f ]_i b ]g `fg `X iZefdc` ]_ ]^\_` ˜e a][ eX[d`ZX_e `X Xu\faXb \ `l\ iZw ad[`g Z_ \e`]Y[Zelh Y \l]uZXf Xf `X l]u\ ]aa\ee `X `l\ ]^\_` ˜e Z_`\fh Z_^ `fde` ]b X_^e` \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ c]f`ZaZc]_`e r _][ e`]`\ r y_ `lZe c]c \f k\ cfXc Xe\ `l\ de\ Xs `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e `X ^d]f]_`\\ ] `fde`\i \_uZfX_b \_`  ™‹ ’“‹ŽŸ “‰’ • sXf `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e r y_ `l\ _\v` e\a`ZX_ k\ cf\e\_` `l\ `\al_Zd\e ]_i t\ elXk lXk `l\e\ `lf\\ ]falZ`\a`df][ \_`Z`Z\e Z_h b X i\[e `l]` k Z[[ Y \ de\i `X YdZ[i Xdf eX[d`ZX_ j k lZ[\ `\f]a` Yg b \]_e Xs ]_ \v ]b c[\ r 3dcc Xe\ 1 [Za\ Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € k\ cf\e\_` `l\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ccfX]al Xs ¡Xk _\f¢ k ]_`e `X e\_ i ]_ ]^\_` `X ] uZf`d][ e`Xf\ mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q X_ k lZal k\ Y]e\i Xdf kXfz r ¡]^\_` c[]a\¢ k Z`l `l\ cdfc Xe\ Xs aX_`f]a`Z_^ `l\ ]ah 4 l\_ j Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ƒ j k\ cf\e\_` Xdf sf]b \kXfz sXf dZeZ`ZX_ Xs ] aXcg Xs `l\ XfZ^Z_][ 5 31 c ]c \f r 4 l\ YdZ[iZ_^ e\adf\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` ege`\b e j ]_i ^Zu\ sX[[Xk Z_^ e`\ce ]f\ \v\ad`\i — ]_ \v ]b c[\ Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ~ r 4 l\ []e` e\a`ZX_ aX_ a[di\e `l\ c ]c \f r nr 1 [Za\ ]adZf\e ]_ ]^\_` j \Z`l\f Yg YdZ[iZ_^ Z` l\fe\[s Xf d eZ_^ eXb \X_\ \[e\ ˜e aX i\ r 1 [Za\ ][eX „ e\`e `l\ ]^\_` ˜e b ZeeZX_ ¡_\^X`Z]`Z_^ `l\ c]c \f¢

…V ]_i ec \aZx\e `l\ b ]vZb db cfZa\ Xs £ n‚ r † ‡ˆ ‰ Š ‹Œ ‰Ž ‰ Œ‹ ‘‹’“ ” •“‹– •  r 1 [Za\ f\[\]e\e l\f ]^\_` `X Z_`\f]a` k Z`l `l\ t\ _Xk i\eafZY \ `l\ ^\_\f][ b X i\[ sXf b XYZ[\ ]^\_` e`Xf\ Z_ Xfi\f `X [X a]`\ `l\ 5 31 c ]c \f ]_i `X ege`\b e de\i `lfXd^lXd` `lZe c ]c \f r t\ xfe` i\h _\^X`Z]`\ Z`e cfZa\ ]_i X`l\f aX_`f]a` Z`\b e r

Begin negotiation

Negotiation

Agreement OK

Finished

Agreement not OK

Aborted

Acceptance Tentative Agreement

Timeout or maximum rounds exceeded

Z^df\ n— 4 l\ cfXc Xe\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ sf]b \kXfz r € r t l\_ `l\ ]^\_` ]_ i `l\ e`Xf\ f\]al ]_ ]^f\\h b Xf\ e`\c `X `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee Yd` Z` ][eX ][h b \_` j ] aX_`f]a` elXd[i Y \ eZ^_\i `X e\``[\ `l\ [Xk de `X d e\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe b Xf\ \w aZ\_`[gj cdfal]e\ r y_ eXb \ a]e\e j `l\ aX_`f]a` eZ^_Z_^ ]e iZeadee\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ƒ r b ]g Y \ f\c[]a\i Yg c]gb \_` ]_ i i\[Zu\fg Xs iZ^Z`][ ^X X ie r † ‡ ‹   Ž‹  ‰ 
Ž‰  ‹••‰Ž• ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` Ze f\[\]e\i `X Z`e _\v` e`Xc r † ‡†

‰ Š ‹Œ ‰Ž –
Œ  ‹Š  “‰– Ÿ“‹Š  ‹  ‘‰“Ÿ“‰’ •

4X Y \ ]Y[\ `X YdZ[i ]^\_`e `l]` a]_ \v\ad`\ _\h ^X`Z]`ZX_ e ]d`Xb ]`Za][[gj k\ _\\i ] i\`\fb Z_Ze`Za b X i\[ sXf _\^X`Z]`ZX_e r t\ sX[[Xk `l\ ]ccfX]al Xs m W  j noooq ]_i d e\ x _Z`\ ]d`Xb ]`] `X b X i\[ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee r 4 l\ cfXc Xe\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ sf]b \kXfz l]e `kX cl]e\e — ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cl]e\ ]_i ]_ ]aa\c`]_ a\ cl]e\ ]e elXk _ Z_ Z^df\ nr 4 l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cl]e\ Ze k l\f\ `l\ ]a`d][ _\^Xh `Z]`ZX_ X aadfe r y_ `lZe cl]e\ j `l\ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` xfe` e\_ie `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ ] i\eafZc`ZX_ Xs `l\ Z`\b e Z` Ze k Z[[Z_^ `X _\^X`Z]`\ r ys `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze ][eX k Z[[Z_^ `X _\^X`Z]`\ ]_ Z`\b `l]` b ]`al\e `l\ i\eafZc`ZX_ j Z` _X`Zx\e `l\ ]^\_` Yg e`]f`Z_^ ] cfX`X aX[ \v al]_^\ k lZal k Z[[ \u\_`d][[g \_i Z_ ]_ ]^f\\b \_` Xf Z_ s]Z[h df\ r ys ]_ ]^f\\b \_` k ]e f\]al\i j `l\ ]^\_` Y \^Z_e `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl ]e\ Xs Z`e _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ][^XfZ`lb r y_ `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl]e\ j `l\ ]^\_` aXb cd`\e ] 2 XX[\]_ sd_a`ZX_  Z_ Xfi\f `X al\az k l\`l\f `l\ ]^f\\b \_` b ]`al\e `l\ Z_`\_i\i ^X][e r 4 l\ ]^\_` aX_a[di\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ X_[g k l\_ `l\ u][d\ Xs  Ze `fd\  X`l\fk Ze\ j `l\ ]^\_` ]Y Xf`e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ r 4 lZe b X i\[ sXf ]d`Xb ]`\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_e ^\_\f][h Z \e X`l\f _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b \`lX ie j edal ]e `l\ X_\ Xs m \g]b ] ]_i W ]i\Zf] j ‚‚ nq j elXk _ Z_ Z^df\  ¡]¢r 4 l\Zf b \`lX i Z_uX[u\e `l\ \v al]_^\ Xs cfXc Xe][e d_`Z[ X_\ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xfe Ze e]`Zex\i ]_i a[Xe\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Yg ]^f\\Z_^ `X `l\ `\fb e cfXc Xe\i Yg Z`e c \\f r 4 l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b ]g ][eX Y \ a[Xe\i Yg ] _\^X`Z]`Xf f\ \a`Z_^ ] cfXc Xe][ k Z`lXd` b ]zZ_^ ] aXd_`\fhcfXc Xe][r 1 `Zb \Xd` b ]g ][eX X aadf ]_i `\fb Z_]`\ `l\ `f]_ e]a`ZX_ r 4X ]i]c` `l\ \g]b ]hW ]i\Zf] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b \`lX i `X Xdfe j k\ ]ii ]_ ]aa\c`]_a\ e`]`\ `X Z`e `f]_eZ`ZX_ iZ]^f]b ¡e\\ Z^df\  ¡Y ¢¢ r 4 lZe ]iie X_\

4X Zb c[\b \_` `l\ ]^\_` e\fu\fe Xf c[]a\e j mt Z[l\[b \` ][rj ‚‚‚q ]iXc`\i ] c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al j k lZal b \]_ e `l]` e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe k\f\ de\i `X ][[Xk `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f `X Y \ a\f`]Z_ `l]` Z`e ]^\_`e a]__X` Y \ `]b c \f\i k Z`l r t\ k Z[[ d e\ `lZe ]eedb c`ZX_ ]e i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ƒ r 1 e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze ] `]b c \fhf\eZe`]_` i\uZa\ `l]` Z_a[di\e ] 6 j ]_ y  y_`\fs]a\ ]_i b \b h Xfg ¡Y X`l 5 1 W ]_i 5  W ¢r y`e Xc \f]`Z_^ eXs`k ]f\ f\eZi\e Z_ `l\ 5  W b X id[\ ]_i `l\ X_[g Z_`\f]ah `ZX_ k Z`l `l\ \v`\f_][ \_uZfX_b \_` Ze iX_\ `lfXd^l ] k\[[hi\x_\i Z_`\fs]a\ r y` Ze aX__\a`\i `X ] lXe` ege`\b `l ]` d e\e `l\ y  Z_`\fs]a\ `X f\d\e` Z`e e\fuZa\e r 3Z_a\ ] e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze `]b c \f f\eZe`]_` ]_i `l\ X_[g Z_`\f]a`ZX_ ][[Xk\i Ze `lfXd^l ] k\[[h i\x_\i Z_`\fs]a\ j k\ `fde` `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `X Y \l]u\ ]e cfX^f]b b \i Yg Z`e b ]_ds]a`df\f r 4 l\ f\]i\f b ]g f\s\f `X mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q sXf ] b Xf\ `lXfXd^l iZeadeeZX_ Xs `fd e` Z_ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` egeh `\b e r  df ^X][ l\f\ Ze `X b Z_Zb Z \ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ `l]` X aadfe Z_ `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r † ‡

Ÿ–
‹Ž 
Ž‰ ‰  ‰–
 “Ÿ“‰’ •

4]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e ]f\ aXb cd`]`ZX_e Z_ k lZal _X \v`\f_][ Z_`\fs\f\_a\ X aadf r 4 l\g e`fZa`[g sX[[Xk ] cf\i\`\fb Z_\i ][^XfZ`lb ]_i Z_`\f]a` k Z`l \v`\f_][ \_`Z`Z\e Z_ k\[[ i\x_\i k ]ge r 4 lZe b \]_e `l]` ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ iX \e _X` [\]z Z_h sXfb ]`ZX_ `X \v`\f_ ][ \_`Z`Z\e k Z`lXd` sX[[Xk Z_^ ] e`fZa` aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[ sXf Z_cd` ]_i Xd`cd` Xs i]`] r 4]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e b X i\[ `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs aX i\ Z_ ]_ \_uZfX_b \_` `fde`\i _X` `X iZefdc` `l\ aX i\ Y \Z_^ \v\ad`\i ]_i ][eX _X` `X \]u\eh ifXc `l\ aXb cd`]`ZX_ Yg Z_ec \a`ZX_ Xs Z`e aX i\ Xf i]`] r 3dal ] `fd e`\i \_uZfX_b \_` a]_ Y \ ]alZ\u\i Yg `l\ de\ Xs e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe j ]e \vc[]Z_\i

Call for proposals

Timeout Requested

Timeout

Offered

Offer

Reject Suggest

Propose

Rejected

Proposed Agree

Agreed

Request

Closed Negotiable
  

 
 
  
  
 



Call for proposals

Timeout Requested

Timeout

Offered

Offer

Reject Suggest

Propose

Rejected

Proposed Agreed

Request Agree Accept

Acceptance

Closed

Negotiable                       ! "   

# $% & ' ( ) * + , ( - ' $% $. / 0 . ( % - 1 $ / 1 $- . 2 3, ( 4 ( / . 5 1 , ( 2 / 4 ( 2 3, ( 4 ( / 5 / 6 1 ( 5 1 - - & ' 4 - 5 ( 0

/7 -8( 9 - ' 1 , '- & % , 1 , (

& 2( -:

; < =>? @

A B CD E
IJ / . 5 ( ' / . 5 + 2 3, & 5 $. 9 KL L MN O

1-

/ 00- T

( $1 , ( '

X G E G Y A< ; D U E >V F W >EH

A< ;D U E>V F

W >EH

@V AB CD E @X A
A< ; Z

J( 3& '( 4 /.Q 1'- . $3 l(1 2

3( 6 1

1-

W >EH

@ V A B CD E @X

XGEG

GV X

A
3 - R 6 ' - 3 ( 2 2- ' 2

, /8 (

/ 6 6 0$ 3 / 1 $- . 2 9 2 & 3,

6 ' - - : 3 - 4 6 & 1 / 1 $- . 2 3 - & 05 7 ( / 3, $( 8 ( 5 & 2 $. % 1 , ( 3 - . R A< ; D U E >V F

#- ' / 2 & ' 8 ( Q

In 1 - / . 5 o / , / 7 9 ) p p KN O

@ V A B CD E @X

D U E >V F W >EH @ V A B CD E @X X G E G G V X A
-:

) OK O

- : 4 - 7 $0( / % ( .1 2 Q 21 ( 4 2 9 1 , ( ' ( / 5 ( ' $ 2 ' ( : ( ' ' ( 5 1 -

P - 7 $0( 3 ' Q 6 1 - % ' / 6 , Q ( . 3 - 4 6 / 2 2( 2 / 2 ( 1 - : 1 ( 3, R . $S& ( 2

1 , ( 2$4 6 0$m ( 5 4 - 5 ( 0 - : J ( 31 $- .

3& ''(. 3Q9

/. 5

2( 3 & ' (

6 0/ . / 1 $- .

1 / 1 $- . , / 2 . - / 3 3 ( 2 2 1 - 1 , ( 4 ( / . $. % - : 1 , ( 3 - 5 ( / . 5

6 ' - 3 ( 2 2- ' 2 O

-:

( 0( 31 ' - . $3

3 - . 1 ' / 31 +,(

& 2( 2

/. 5

:- '

/

6 ' - 6 - 2( 5

:- '

6 ' - 1 ( 31 $- . 9 ( 0( 3R

6 - 21 / % ( O

Iq( ( / . 5 + Q % / ' 9 KL L rN

T , $ 3, 4 ( / . 2 1 , / 1 1 , ( ( . 1 $1Q ( [ ( 3 & 1 $. % 1 , ( 3 - 4 6 & R

7 ((.

/2 3-6Q

/ & 31 $- .

'( / 5 ( ' 4 -'(

/ ' 3, $1 ( 31 & ' ( 2

$2

4 / 'R

'(:(''( 5

5 ( 1 / $0( 5 -:

2( 3& '(

([ R 3-R

5 / 1 / 7 ( $. % & 2 ( 5 O

\ ]^

_ ` ab c ` d e f g h

P /.Q

2 Q 21 ( 4 2

( [ ( 3 & 1 $- .

-:

, /8 (

4 - 7 $0(

2 3 ' $6 1 - ' ij / . 1 / O 4 - 7 $0(

/% (.1 2

7 ((. /% (.1 2

s

/. 5

' ( 0( / 2(

u v w wxy xwz x{

t u u _ |t {}

z|

z _ ~ wz  | _ y | € x v t ‚ v ƒ z w 6 '- 6 - 2( 5 2 & 3,

/2

1-

/ 00- T

i % 0( 1 2 9

1,(

+( 0( R

k . 1 , ( 2( 2 Q 21 ( 4 2 9 ( . 1 $1 $( 2 5 ( 2 $% .

8 $2 $1 / % ( .1 2 ( ' 8 ( ' 2 O

t

1,(4

-.

/

. ( 1T - ' l

1-

P - 21 4 - 7 $0( / % ( . 1 2 Q 21 ( 4 2 m 1

I„ $0, ( 04 ( 1 / 0 O9 ) p p pN

6 ' ( 2( .1

/.

/ 6 6 ' - / 3,

:- '

7 & $05 $. % 4 - 7 $0( / % ( . 1 6 0/ 1 : - ' 4 2 $. T , $ 3, 1 , ( / % ( .1 -T . ('

5- (2 .-1

1 ' & 21

1, (

6 0/ 3( 2

T ,('(

1,(

/ % ( .1

( [ ( 3 & 1 ( 2 O k . 21 ( / 5 9 1 , ( 1 ' & 21 $ 2 6 0 / 3 ( 5 - . 1 , ( 4 / . & R

s]a`df\f Xs ] e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ege`\b k l\f\ `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ \v\ad`\ r t Z`l `lZe elZs` j t Z[l\[b \` ][r f\]eX_ `l ]` ]_ Xc \_ b ]fz\`c[]a\ Xs ]^\_` \v\adh `ZX_ e\fu\fe b ]g ]fZe\ k Z`l b Z[[ZX_e Xs c]f`ZaZc]_`e j Yd` `l\ `fde` f\[]`ZX_ elZce b ]g Y \ f\e`fZa`\i `X ] s\k aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\fe r 4 lXe\ b ]_ds]ah `df\fe aXd[i `l\_ Y \ edY \a`\i `X Xw aZ][ Z_ec \ah `ZX_e ]_i f\cd`]`ZX_ al\aze j `X b ]z\ edf\ `l\g l]u\ _X Y \_\x` Z_ Yf\]zZ_^ `lZe `fde` f\[]`ZX_elZc r y_ mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q aXhcfX a\eeXfe ]f\ de\i `X Zb h c[\b \_` `]b c \fhcfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_e sXf ][[ ]^\_`e r y_ `lZe e\a`ZX_ j k\ i\eafZY \ `l\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al Xs t Z[l\[b \` ][ r Zfe` j k\ cf\e\_` `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b X i\[ `l\g de\ j `l\_ i\`]Z[ `l\ cfXh c Xe\i aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[ sXf e\_iZ_^ ]^\_`e `X \v\ad`ZX_ e\fu\fe r 1 iZeadeeZX_ Xs `l\ [Zb Z`]`ZX_e Xs `l\Zf ]ccfX]al aX_a[di\e `l\ e\a`ZX_ r

cfX a\eeXf a]_ cfX`\a` cfZu]`\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ a]ffZ\i Yg ]^\_`e \v\ad`Z_^ Z_eZi\ Z` r ys `l\ Xk _\f Xs ]_ ]^\_` `fde`e `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\f `X l]u\ YdZ[` Z` aXff\a`[gj `l\ Xk _\f a]_ Y \ ]eedf\i `l]` `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ \v\ad`\ aXff\a`[g ]_ i k Z[[ _X` [\]z e\_eZh `Zu\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ `X d_]d`lXfZ \i c]f`Z\e r

 ‡†

 ‰– –  ’  Ÿ“‰’ ž Ž‰“‰  ‰Œ

y_ Xfi\f `X [\u\f]^\ `l\ e\adfZ`g c X`\_`Z][ Xs `l\ e\h adf\ cfX a\eeZ_^ \_uZfX_b \_`  d e` i\eafZY \i j ] aXb h b d_Za]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[ l]e Y \\_ i\x_\i `X ][[Xk `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f `X e\adf\[g i\[Zu\f ]^\_`e `X Y \ \v\h ad`\i Yg ]^\_` c[]a\e r 4 lZe cfX`X aX[ Ze de\i `X `f]_es\f ]^\_`e ]b X_^e` `l\ c]f`Z\e Z_uX[u\i ]_ i ^d]f]_`\\e `l]` X_[g `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze ]Y[\ `X i\afgc` ]_i \v\ad`\ `l\ ]^\_` r 4 l\ b ]Z_ Zi\] Y \lZ_i `l\ cfX`X aX[ Ze `l]` ]^\_`e  ‡ˆ ž Ž‰  ‹••’‘ ‹’ Ž‰’– ‹’“ elXd[i Y \ e\_` ]_i f\b ]Z_ \_afgc`\i d_`Z[ `l\g ]f\ mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q cfXc Xe\ ]_ ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ Z_e`]_`Z]`\i Z_ `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` r Xf `l]` cdfc Xe\ j `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^ edcc XeZ`ZX_e ]f\ \_uZfX_b \_` aXb cfZe\i Xs ] lXe` aXb cd`\f k Z`l ]_ b ]i\ — ¡Z¢ `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ l]e ] cdY[Zahz\g a\f`Zxh ]``]al\i e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf j k l\f\ `l\ ]a`d][ \v\h a]`\ sXf Z`e aXhcfX a\eeXf z\g c]Zf  ¡ZZ¢ `l\ c[]a\ iX \e ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ l]cc \_ r 4 l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf _X` l]u\ ]aa\ee `X `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ˜e cfZu]`\ z\g  b de` cfXuZi\ ] aXb c[\`\ ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ \_uZfX_h ¡ ]_i ZZZ¢ `l\ c[]a\ Ze f\^Ze`\f\i k Z`lZ_ ] iZf\a`Xfg b \_` eZ_a\ `l\ lXe` aXb cd`\f Ze _X` `fd e`\i ]_i 4 e\fuZa\ r l\ cfX`X aX[ Ze aXb cfZe\i Yg `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^ k Z[[ X_[g cfXuZi\ aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ e\fuZa\e sXf `l\ aXh e`\ce — cfX a\eeXf ]_i `l\ ]^\_`e Z` \v\ad`\e r 4 l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `l\g \_uZeZX_ Y X X`e sfXb aX i\ e`Xf\i Z_ 5  W b \b Xfg Z_eZi\ Z` r 4 lZe aX i\ nr 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f de\e `l\ iZf\a`Xfg e\fuZa\e `X k Z[[ Z_a[d i\ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Xc \f]`Z_^ ege`\b ]_i x_i ] edZ`]Y[\ ]^\_` c[]a\ j XY`]Z_e Z`e [X a]`ZX_ ][eX ] uZf`d][ b ]alZ_\ \_uZfX_b \_` j edal ]e `l\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ j Z`e c X[Zag e`]`\b \_` j ]_i `l\ a\fh
]u] []_^d]^\ uZf`d][ b ]alZ_\ j Z_ k lZal `l\ ]^\_`e `Zx a]`\ sXf Z`e e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r \v\ad`\ r 4 l\ de\ Xs ] uZf`d][ b ]alZ_\ ^Zu\e ] d_Zh sXfb c[]`sXfb sXf ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ j \u\_ Zs iZš\f\_`  r 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f u\fZx\e `l]` `l\ c[]a\ c X[Zag l]fik ]f\ Xf Xc \f]`Z_^ ege`\b c[]`sXfb e ]f\ de\i r e]`Zex \e Z`e _\\ie ]_i `l]` `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze y` ][eX cfX`\a`e `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` ]Y[\ `X \_sXfa\ `lZe c X[Zagr sfXb b ZeY \l]uZ_^ Xf b ][ZaZXde ]^\_`e r 1 [eX Z_a[di\i Z_ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze ] afgc`Xh € r ys `l\ c X[Zag edZ`e `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f j Z` e\_ie ^f]clZa [ZYf]fgj k lZal cfXuZi\e `l\ afgc`X^f]clZa `l\ ]^\_` `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ j \_afgc`\i k Z`l sd_a`ZX_e _\\i\i Yg `l\ ]^\_`e `X e\adf\ `l\b e\[u\e `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ˜e cdY[Za z\g cf\e\_` Z_ `l\ aXh Xf `X \e`]Y[Zel e\adf\ aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ al ]__\[e k Z`l cfX a\eeXf ˜e a\f`Zx a]`\ r `l\Zf Xk _\fe r 4 lZe [ZYf]fg Z_a[di\e ] z\g c]Zf j `X Y \ de\i Z_ cdY[Zahz\g afgc`X^f]clZa Xc \f]`ZX_e r 4 l\ ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ f\[]ge `l\ ]^\_` `X `l\ aXh e\af\ag Xs `l\ cfZu]`\ c Xf`ZX_ Xs `lZe z\g c]Zf Ze cfX a\eeXf sXf \v\ad`ZX_ r c]f]b Xd_` `X `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ cfXc Xe\i eal\b \ j ]_i Ze ^d]f]_`\\i Yg `l\ `]b c \fhf\eZe`]_ a\ Xs `l\ ~ r 4 l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf i\afgc`e `l\ ]^\_` ]_i Z_h aXhcfX a\eeXf r e`]_`Z]`\e Z` `X e`]f` \v\ad`ZX_ r 4 l\ []e` aXb c X_\_` Xs `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze `l\ y_cd`  d`cd` b X id[\ j k lZal \_sXfa\e ] k\[[h | r 1s`\f `l\ ]^\_` x _Zel\e \v\ad`ZX_ j `l\ aXh i\x _\i Z_`\fs]a\ k Z`l `l\ lXe` aXb cd`\f r 4 l\ sX[h cfX a\eeXf f\`df_e Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ [Xk Z_^ Xc \f]`ZX_ e b de` Y \ cfXuZi\i Yg `l\ y  ]_i b ]g f\d\e` ]^\_` b Z^f]`ZX_ `X Z`e Xk _\f b X id[\ — Xf ]_X`l\f c[]a\ r  dc[X]i j b Z^f]`ZX_ ]_i f\b Xu][ Xs ]^\_`e 

4 l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]g ][eX ][[Xk `l\ ]^\_` `X e`Xf\ Z`e Zi\_`Z`g ]_i eXb \ ]iiZ`ZX_ ][ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ Z_ Z`e c \feZe`\_` e`Xf]^\ `X ]uXZi f\c[]g ]``]aze sfXb `l\  Z_`\f_][ e`]`\ d\fZ\e j ed al ]e k lZal ]^\_`e ]f\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r 4 lZe Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ b ]g Y \ al\az\i Yg adff\_`[g fd__Z_^ r `l\ ]^\_` Y \sXf\ Z` e`]f`e \v\ad`Z_^ j Z_ Xfi\f `X cf\h t Z`l `l\ ]aa\ee f\e`fZa`ZX_ \_sXfa\i Yg `l\ y  u\_` `l\ c[]a\e sfXb al\]`Z_^ Yg fd__Z_^ `l\ e]b \ b X id[\ ]_i Z`e `]b c \f f\eZe`]_a\ j `l\ e\adf\ aXh ]^\_` b ]_g `Zb \e r  aXb b d_Za]`ZX_e Y \`k\\_ lXe`e ]_ i ]^\_`e 

 ‡

 – “Ÿ“‰’ •

3Xb \ [Zb Z`]`ZX_e Xs `lZe ]ccfX]al ]f\ —  4]b c \fhcfX Xs l]fik ]f\ Ze iZw ad[` `X YdZ[i ]_i

]^\_`e j \]al k Z`l ] ec \aZx a b ZeeZX_ — ]     ]_ i ]_i     r 4 l\e\ `kX b ]z\ dc Xdf   r 4 lZe sf]b \kXfz Ze elXk _ Z_ Z^h df\ € r

elXd[i Y \ Z_ec \a`\i c \fZX iZa][[g `X cfXuZi\ `]b c \fZ_^ i\`\a`ZX_ r ys eXb \ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze    ™ ‹  ‹‘‰“Ÿ“‰’ ‘‹’“ `]b c \f\i k Z`l j `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ b ]g Y \ ]Y[\ `X 4 l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` \v\ad`\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ^]`l\f aX_x i\_`Z][ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ a]ffZ\i Yg `l\ cl]e\ Xs `l\ b X i\[ cf\e\_`\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_  r r 4 lZe ]^\_`e r Z_a[d i\e Y X`l e\``Z_^ `l\ ]Zb Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_ i ][eX \v\ad`Z_^ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[j d eZ_^ `l\ 3\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe d ed][[g l ]u\ e\u\f\ aXe`  ]_ i c \fsXfb ]_a\ aX_e`f]Z_`e id\ `X `l\ iZw h e`f]`\^g i\x_\i Yg Z`e Xk _\f r 4 lZe ]^\_` Ze \v\h ad[`g Xs `l\Zf aX_e`fda`ZX_ r 4X Y \ cf]a`Za][ j ] ad`\i d_`Z[ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ [\]ie `X ]_ ]^f\\b \_` e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfhY]e\i eal\b \ elXd[i b Z_h Xf Z` Ze ]Y Xf`\i ¡Yg `Zb \Xd` Xf Yg ]_g Xs `l\ c]f`Zah Zb Z \ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ f\dZf\i `X Zc]_`e¢r y` `l\_ e\_ie `l\ cfXec \a`Zu\ ]^f\\b \_` `X Y \ \v\ad`\i Yg `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r t\ i\][ k Z`l `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` sXf u][Zi]`ZX_ ]_i ]aa\c`]_a\ r y` Ze a[\]f `l]` j eZ_a\ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` Ze _X` `lZe f\e`fZa`ZX_ Z_ `l\ _\v` e\a`ZX_ r \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ j `l\ ]^\_`  4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\fe b d e` `fde` `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf c[]a\ Ze ]Y[\ `X \]u\eifXc Z`e aX i\ ]_i i]`] ]_ i b ]_ds]a`df\fe r ys `lZe `fde` f\[]`ZX_elZc a]_h ][eX `X Z_`\fs\f\ k Z`l Z`e \v\ad`ZX_ j c XeeZY[g [\]iZ_^ _X` Y \ \e`]Y[Zel\i j `lZe ]ccfX]al a]__X` Y \ i\h `X ]_ Xd`aXb \ _X` ]aa\c`]Y[\ `X `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f r c[Xg\i r 1 [eX j `lZe ]^\_` a]__X` a]ffg aX_x i\_`Z][ Z_sXfb ]h `ZX_ j edal ]e cfZu]`\ z\ge Xf c]gb \_` Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ j ž   ž 
V ž 

     k lZal aXd[i [\]z `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r y_ `lZe e\a`ZX_ j k\ iZead ee Xdf cfXc Xe][ `X Zb cfXu\ `l\ \w aZ\_ag Xs `l\ de\ Xs `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]h `ZX_e sXf _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_`e r t\ xfe` cf\e\_` ] ^\_h \f][ sf]b \kXfz j `l\_ k\ elXk lXk `lZe sf]b \kXfz a]_ Y \ Zb c[\b \_`\i deZ_^ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe r Zh _][[gj k\ iZead ee lXk `l\ aX_a\c` Xs
     a]_ [\]i `X ]_ ][`\f_]`Zu\ eX[d`ZX_ r

 ‡ˆ

 ‹’ ‹ŽŸŒ ŽŸ– ‹› ‰Ž  ‰Ž

‘‹’“   Ÿ•‹Š  ‹‘‰“Ÿ“‰’ •

‹   Ž‹

{ \^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_`e b d e` b Z^f]`\ `X ]^\_` c[]a\e ¡ded][[g uZf`d][ e`Xf\e Zb c[\b \_`\i ]e ]^\_` c[]a\e¢ `X _\^X`Z]`\ ]^f\\b \_`e X_ Y \l][s Xs `l\Zf Xk _\fe r 4 l\g b d e` `l\_ \v\ad`\ Z_ c XeeZY[g d_`fde`\i \_uZh fX_b \_`e r y_ Xfi\f `X \e`]Y[Zel ] e\adf\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ e\``Z_^ j `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e a]_ Y \ de\i j ]e cf\e\_`\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € r 1 e `lZe a]_ [\]i `X c \fh sXfb ]_a\ ]_i aXe` c \_][`Z\e `l ]` kXd[i b ]z\ `lZe ]ccfX]al d_]aa\c`]Y[\ j Z` Ze _\a\ee]fg `X f\ida\ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs `]b c \fhcfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_ e de\i r 4X f\id a\ `l\ Xu\fl\]i Z_`fX ida\i Yg `]b c \fh cfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_e j Z` Ze c XeeZY[\ `X \v\ad`\ X_[g `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl]e\ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]e ] `]b c \fh cfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_ j [\]uZ_^ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cl ]e\ Z_ e\adf\ r 1 e ed al j `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_  r a]_ Y \ d e\i `X c]f`Z`ZX_ ]^\_`e Z_ `kX c ]f`e — X_\ Zb c[\b \_`Z_^ `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ e`]`\ ]_ i Z`e f\[]`\i `f]_eZ`ZX_e j ]_ i `l\ X`l\f Zb c[\b \_`Z_^ `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ e`]`\ ]_ i f\[]`\i `f]_eZ`ZX_e r 4 lZe b \]_ e `l]` `l\ xfe` c]f` Xs `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ Y \ f\ec X_eZY[\ sXf `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Xs `l\ ]^f\\b \_` ]_i `l\ e\aX_i c ]f` l]e `l\ f\ec X_eZYZ[Z`g Xs u][Zi]`Z_^ ]_i ]aa\c`Z_^ Xf _X` `l\ ]^f\\b \_` r 4X b ]z\ `lZe sf]b \kXfz \]eZ\f `X Zb c[\b \_` Z_ adff\_` ]^\_` ege`\b e j k\ aX_eZi\f `kX Z_i\c \_i\_`

 

 ™ ‹   ‹
“Ÿ’  ‹ ‘‹’“

1s`\f `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` l]e f\]al\i ]_ ]^f\\h b \_` j Z` b de` aXb b d_Za]`\ `l\ `\fb e Xs `lZe ]^f\\h b \_` `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ ]^\_` j k lZal k Z[[ \v\ad`\ `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl]e\ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ r 3Z_ a\ `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ cl ]e\ Xs `l\ b X i\[ b de` Y \ \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ j `lZe ]^\_` Z`e\[s Ze f\dZf\i `X Y \ \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` b de` \v\ad`\ `l\ ]aa\ch `]_ a\ sd_ a`ZX_ i\x _\i Yg `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ ]_ i ]aa\c` Xf f\ \a` `l\ ]^f\\b \_` Y]e\i X_ Z`e f\ed[` r ys Z` ]aa\c`e `l\ ]^f\\b \_` j Z` Ze f\dZf\i `X Xd`cd` ] `\fb hXsh]aa\c`]_a\ j k lZal u]fZ\e ]aaXfiZ_^ `X `l\ _\\ie Xs `l\ c]f`Z\e Z_uX[u\i r y` b ]g Y \ ] u][Zi eZ^h _]`df\ sXf `l\ ]^f\\b \_` j ] af\iZ` a]fi _db Y \f Xf \u\_ ]_ \[\a`fX_Za c]gb \_` Xfi\f r

 

 ‰’ •Š‹ŽŸ“‰’•

fXb `l\ i\eafZc`ZX_ ]Y Xu\ j X_\ a]_ aX_a[di\ `l]` `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ ege`\b Ze Y]e\i X_ `l\ s]a` `l]` `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ ]^\_` Ze \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r fXb `lZe j `kX d\e`ZX_e ]fZe\ — nr ye `l\ ec[Z``Z_^ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xf de\sd[   r t l]` Ze `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `lZe ]ccfX]al  4 l\ ]_ek\f `X `l\ xfe` d\e`ZX_ Ze g\e — `l\ ec[Z`h `Z_^ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xf Ze de\sd[ eZ_a\ Z` f\ida\e `l\ aXb cd`]`ZX_][ c Xk\f _\\i\i sXf `l\ e\adf\ aXb cdh `]`ZX_ j k lZal [Xk\fe `l\ aXe` Xs YdZ[iZ_^ `lZe eX[dh `ZX_ k l\_ aXb c]f\i `X `l\ ]ccfX]al i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € r 4 lZe aXe` f\ida`ZX_ k Z[[ _X` X_[g b ]z\ `lZe eX[d`ZX_ cf]a`Za][ Yd` k Z[[ ][eX ][[Xk sXf ] k Zi\f i\c[Xgb \_` Xs `lZe ]ccfX]al r

Negotiation Agent

Acceptance Agent Tamper-proof computation

Agent Place

Z^df\ € — 4 kX c]f`e Xs ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` ys `l\ cfXc Xe\i Zb c[\b \_`]`ZX_ Ze ]iXc`\i k Z`lh Xd` `l\ aX_adff\_` de\ Xs aXb c[\b \_`]fg e\adfZ`g b \]edf\e j Z` b ]g l]u\ ] e\adfZ`g [\u\[ `l]` Ze Z_s\h fZXf `X `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ cdf\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ccfX]al Xs 3\a`ZX_ € r  df cfXc Xe][ elXd[i Y \ e\\_ ]e ] lgh YfZi ]ccfX]al `l]` b Z_Zb Z \e `l\ [\u\[ Xs `fde` `l]` b de` Y \ c[]a\i X_ `l\ ]^\_ ag Yg `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f r 4 lZe Ze eX Y \a]de\ `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ˜e \v\ad`ZX_ ]e ] e\adf\ aXb cd`]`ZX_ ][[Xk e `l\ Xk _\f `X [Zb Z` `l\ i]b ]^\ ] al\]`Z_^ ]^\_ag a]_ b ]z\ r 3Z_a\ `lZe Ze ] lgYfZi ]ccfX]al j e\adfZ`g b \]edf\e ded][[g `]z\_ Z_  
  

 a]_ Y \ de\i l\f\ `X Zb cfXu\ `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ eal\b \ r 3Xb \ Xs `l\e\ b \]edf\e ]f\ aX i\ XYsdea]`ZX_ m
Xl[ j noopq ]_i eX aZ][ aX_`fX[e mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q r 6X i\ XYh sdea]`ZX_ aX_ eZe`e Z_ l\dfZe`Zae `l ]` ][`\f `l\ aX i\ ]_i i]`] Xs ] cfX^f]b j b ]zZ_^ Z` iZw ad[` `X ]dh `Xb ]`Za][[g f\`fZ\u\ `l\ XfZ^Z_][ aX i\ ]_i i]`] Xf `X Z_s\f `l\ Y \l]uZXf Xs `l\ cfX^f]b r 3X aZ][ aX_h `fX[e aX_ eZe` cfZb ]fZ[g Xs [\^Ze[]`Zu\ Xf e\[sh\_sXfa\i f\^d[]`ZX_ j e\``Z_^ k l ]` aX_e`Z`d`\e `l\ aXff\a` Y \h l]uZXf sXf ]^\_aZ\e ]_ i ]^\_`e j ]_i \_sXfaZ_^ `lZe Y \l]uZXf Yg cd_Zelb \_` Xs `l\ c \fc \`f]`Xfe r 1 _h X`l\f eX aZ][ aX_`fX[ `l]` b ]g Y \ u\fg \š\a`Zu\ Ze Y[]az[Ze`Z_^ j k lZal kXd[i i\af\]e\ `l\ Z_ a\_`Zu\ sXf al\]`Z_^ Y \l]uZXf r y_ edb b ]fgj Xdf ]ccfX]al aXb YZ_\e `l\ ea][]h YZ[Z`g ]_i c \fsXfb ]_a\ Xs `l\  
  

     Z_ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` ege`\b e k Z`l eXb \ e`fX_^ ^d]f]_`\\e Xs Y \l ]uZXf j ][`lXd^l _X` eX e`fX_^ ]e Z_ `l\  
  

     Xs 3\a`ZX_ € r 4 lZe lgYfZi ]ccfX]al k Zi\_e `l\ ec \a`fdb Xs i\h c[Xgb \_` Xs ]^\_`hY]e\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_e j k lZ[\ [Zb Z`h Z_^ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs i]b ]^\ ] al\]`Z_^ ]^\_ag a]_ Z_  Za` `X ]^\_` Xk _\fe r

 ‡†

 ŸŽŠ› ŸŽ‹   Ÿ•‹Š

–
Œ‹– ‹’“Ÿ“‰’

1 e i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € j e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe ]f\ `l\ ded][ b \]_ e sXf Zb c[\b \_`Z_^ `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e k l\_ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\f Ze ] `fd e`\i \_`Z`gr  \` de ]eedb \ l\f\]s`\f `l]` ed al `fde`\i e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe ]f\ ]u]Z[]Y[\ ]` \]al ]^\_` c[]a\ j \]al c Xee\eeZ_^ ]_ ]eeX aZ]`\i afgc`X^f]clZa z\g c]Zf r 4 l\ cfX`X aX[ sXf `l\ \v\adh `ZX_ Xs ] _\^X`Z]`Xf Ze `l\_ i\x _\i Yg `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^

e`\ce — nr 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f YdZ[ie _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_i ]aa\ch `]_a\ ]^\_`e r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` b ]g aX_h `]Z_ aX_x i\_`Z][ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ r  r 4 l\ Xk _\f \_afgc`e `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` k Z`l `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ˜e a\f`Zx\i cdY[Za z\gr € r 4 l\ Xk _\f e\_ie Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ sXf \v\ad`ZX_ r ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ e\_ie `l\ \_ afgc`\i ]aa\ch `]_a\ ]^\_` `X `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ]_i Y \h ^Z_e \v\ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` r ~ r 1s`\f `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` x_Zel\e Z`e \v\h ad`ZX_ j Z` e\_ie Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` j k lZal Ze fd__Z_^ X_ `l\ e\adf\ aXh cfX a\eeXf r | r 4 l\ f\ed[`e Xs `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ]f\ f\[]g\i Yg `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` b ]g de\ c \feZe`\_a\ Xf X`l\f e\fuZa\e cfXuZi\i Yg `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `X cfXh `\a` Z`e\[s sfXb b ZeY \l ]uZ_^ ]^\_` c[]a\e j ]e iZeh adee\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € r

 ‡

‰“› ŸŽ‹  ‰’ Œ” –
Œ‹– ‹’“Ÿ“‰’

W XYZ[\ afgc`X^f]clgj ]e i\x _\i Z_ m3]_i\f ]_i 4 ealdiZ_ j noopq j Ze _X` g\` ] f\h ][Z`g Yd` Z`e aX_a\c`e aXd[i Y \ de\i `X YdZ[i 1 eedb Z_^ `l ]` ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e r b \`lX i sXf 
             Ze c XeeZY[\ j Xdf sf]b \kXfz aXd[i Y \ Zb c[\b \_`\i ]e sX[[Xk e — nr 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f YdZ[ie `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_i ]ah a\c`]_a\ ]^\_`e r  r 4 l\ Xk _\f \_afgc`e `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ ]^\_` deZ_^ b XYZ[\ afgc`X^f]clgj ]_i e\_ie Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r € r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ \v\ad`\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` ]_i f\[]ge Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` r

ƒ r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` Ze fd_ `X Xd`cd` ] eZ^_\i ]^f\\b \_` r

ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ f\[]ge `l\ \_afgc`\i ]^\_` `X Z`e aXhcfX a\eeXf ]_ i Y \^Z_ e \v\ad`Z_^ `l\ _\^Xh `Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` r

3Z_a\ Y X`l aX i\ ]_i i]`] sXf `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ]f\ aX_ a\][\i j Z`e \v\ad`ZX_ a]_ Y \ aX_eZi\f\i ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ ]_i `l\ e\adfZ`g iZeadeh eZX_ sXf Xdf sf]b \kXfz Ze u][Zi Z_ `lZe aX_`\v` r

~ r t l\_ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` x_Zel\e Z`e \v\adh `ZX_ j Z` e\_ie Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` fd__Z_^ X_ `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r 4 l\ ]aa\ch `]_a\ ]^\_` u\fZx \e `lXe\ f\ed[`e ]_ i Zeed\e ] c]gb \_` Xfi\f Zs `l\ u\fZx a]`ZX_ Ze edaa\eesd[r



ž


| r 4 l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf u][Zi]`\e `l\ c ]gb \_` 1 ^X X i ]cc[Za]`ZX_ sXf ]^\_`hY]e\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Ze Xfi\f ]_i f\[]ge Z` `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ j k l\f\ edcc[Z\fe e\` dc \[\ah `fX_Za e`Xf\e `l]` a]_ Y \ uZeZ`\i Yg YdgZ_^ ]^\_`e r  r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ f\[]ge Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\Zf _\v` 4 lXe\ ]^\_`e _\^X`Z]`\ k Z`l `l\ e`Xf\ `X cdfal]e\ e`Xc r `l\ Z`\b e i\eZf\i Yg `l\Zf Xk _\fe ]` ]aa\c`]Y[\ aX_h iZ`ZX_e ¡cfZa\ j i\[Zu\fg `gc \ ]_i i]`\ ]_i eX X_ ¢r 4 lZe ]cc[Za]`ZX_ x`e k\[[ k Z`l Xdf cfXc Xe\i 1 [`lXd^l `l\ i\[Zu\fg Xs `l\ cdfal]e\ Ze _X` c]f` Xs `lZe cfX`X aX[ j Z` b ]g Y \ Z_ a[di\i Z_ Z` Zs `l\ XY \a` sf]b \kXfz eZ_a\ — Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]f\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ ^XX ie Xf Zs `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze f\dZf\i `X Zeed\ ] f\a\Zc` r y_ `lZe `l\ ]^\_` a]_ \]eZ[g de\ Xdf _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[   a]e\ j `lXe\ Z`\b e b ]g Y \ i\[Zu\f\i \[\a`fX_Za][[g `X  `l\ \[\a`fX_Za e`Xf\ a]_ Y \ Zb c[\b \_`\i ]e ]_ `l\ ]^\_` Xf iZf\a`[g `X Z`e Xk _\f r ]^\_` c[]a\   `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ a]_ cfXuZi\ ] e\adf\ aXh

cfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` sXf `l\ YdgZ_^ ]^\_`e r

4 lde j \]al edcc[Z\f YdZ[ie ]_ ]^\_` c[]a\ `l]` cfXuZi\e ] e`]_i]fi 1 y sXf uZf`d][ e`Xf\ Z_`\f]a`ZX_ k Z`l b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e r 4 l\e\ ]^\_` c[]a\e k Z[[ ][eX cfXuZi\ ] e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf k l\f\ ]^\_`e a]_ Y \ \v\ad`\i r 4 lZe ^Zu\e ]^\_` Xk _\fe ¡`l\ ade`Xb \fe¢ `l\ al]_ a\ `X \v\ad`\ `l\ \_`Zf\ YdgZ_^ ]^\_` Z_ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` ¡`l\ ]ccfX]al sfXb mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q¢ Xf `X de\ Xdf sf]b \kXfz ]_i \v\ad`\ X_[g c]f` Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xf ]e ] `]b c \fh cfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r y_ `lZe \v ]b c[\ j k\ ]eedb \ `l\ \vZe`\_a\ Xs ] aXb b \faZ][ \[\a`fX_Za c]gb \_` cfXuZi\f `l]` c[]ge `l\ fX[\ Xs aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\f r 1 e `l\ de\ Xs \[\a`fX_Za c]gb \_` ege`\b e ded][[g f\dZf\e `fde` X_ Z`e cfXuZi\f j k\ b ]g [\u\f]^\ `lZe _\\i ]_i f\h dZf\ ][[ c]gb \_` ege`\b de\fe `X `fde` `l\ cfXuZi\f Y X`l `X aXff\a`[g b ]_ ]^\ `l\ c]gb \_` ege`\b ]_i ][eX `X cfXuZi\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe sXf ]^\_` c[]a\e r y_ elXf` j ][[ d e\fe `fde` `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe `X aXfh f\a`[g l ]_i[\ c]gb \_` Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ r  Zu\_ `lXe\ e\``Z_^e j ]_g \_`Z`g k Z[[Z_^ `X b ]z\ ] cdfal]e\ kXd[i \v\ad`\ `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^ e`\c e —



       

1 ^\_`hY]e\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ege`\b e ]f\ u\fg d e\sd[ `X \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ e\``Z_^e j eZ_a\ `l\g ][[Xk `l\ ]d`Xb ]`ZX_ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee `X f\ida\ aXe`e ]_i i\[]ge r 1 [`lXd^l b ]_g ]^\_` _\^X`Z]h `ZX_ ege`\b e ]f\ Y \Z_^ YdZ[` j `l\g ded][[g iX _X` ]iif\ee `l\ _\\i Xs `l\ ]^\_`e `X Y \ e\adf\i sfXb b ][ZaZXd e ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ \_uZfX_b \_`e Xf `l\ _\\i Xs ]^\_`e `X eZ^_ ]^f\\b \_`e Xf \v\ad`\ c]gb \_`e ]d`X_Xb Xde[g X_ Y \l][s Xs `l\Zf Xk _\fe r y_ `lZe c ]c \f j k\ ]i]c`\i `l\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al Xs mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q `X `l\ aX_`\v` Xs _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_`e ]_i Zb cfXu\i Z`e c \fsXfb ]_a\ Yg \v\ad`Z_^ X_[g c]f` Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee X_ `l\ aX_e`f]Z_\i \_uZfX_b \_` Xs ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r t\ iZi `lZe Yg i\x_Z_^ ] _\^X`Z]h `ZX_ b X i\[ `l ]` c]f`Z`ZX_e ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Z_ `kX Z_h i\c \_i\_` cl]e\e j k Z`l `l\ b Xe` f\eXdfa\ Z_`\_eZu\ cl]e\ _X` f\dZfZ_^ `X Y \ \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fh cfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r 4 lZe ][[Xk e `l\ f\ida`ZX_ Xs `l\ c \fsXfb ]_a\ f\dZf\b \_`e Xs `l\ `]b c \fhcfX Xs \_uZfX_b \_` ]_i `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs ] ^f\]`\f _db Y \f Xs ]^\_`e deZ_^ `l\ e]b \ \_uZfX_b \_` r

nr 5 \^Ze`\f k Z`l `l\ c ]gb \_` ege`\b cfXuZi\f `X Y \aXb \ ]_ ]d`lXfZ \i c]gb \_` Zeed\f r

  

 r 2 dZ[i ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` k Z`l `l\ _\a\ee]fg Z_h `\[[Z^\_ a\ `X _\^X`Z]`\ `l\ i\eZf\i Z`\b e ]_i ]_ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ]Y[\ `X u\fZsg `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_ i Zeed\ `l\ aXff\ec X_iZ_^ c ]gb \_` ]aaXfiZ_^ `X `l\ c]gb \_` ege`\b Z_ de\ r

m6l\ee j noopq 6l\ee j  r W r ¡ noop¢r 3\adfZ`g Zeed\e Z_ b XYZ[\ aX i\ ege`\b e r y_ Z^_ ] j  rj \iZ`Xf j          j _db Y \f nƒ no Z_  \a`df\ { X`\e Z_ 6Xb cd`\f 3aZ\_a\ j c]^\e n nƒ r 3cfZ_^\fh \f[]^ r

€r

m
Xl[ j noopq
Xl[ j r ¡ noop¢ r 4 Zb \ [Zb Z`\i Y[]azh Y Xv e\adfZ`g — fX`\a`Z_^ b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e sfXb b ]h [ZaZXde lXe`e r y_ Z^_] j  rj \iZ`Xf j       j _db Y \f nƒ no Z_  \a`df\ { X`\e Z_ 6Xb h cd`\f 3aZ\_a\ r 3cfZ_^\fh \f[]^ r

 X a]`\

]_ ]ccfXcfZ]`\ \[\a`fX_Za e`Xf\ j ^\` Z`e aXhcfX a\eeXf a\f`Zx a]`\ j \_afgc` `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` k Z`l `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf cdY[Za z\g ]_i e\_i Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\ \[\a`fX_Za e`Xf\ ˜e ]^\_` c[]a\ r

mW ]b Y X \` ][rj noo|q W ]b Y X j W rj edi] j rj ]_i  z]b X`X j
r ¡ noo|¢ r fXvg eZ^_]`df\e —  \[\^]h `ZX_ Xs `l\ c Xk\f `X eZ^_ b \ee]^\e r         
 j
 oh1 ¡o¢—n€€p  n€~ƒ r

     

 
       r

m W  j noooq  W  ¡ nooo¢ r

 Y \a` W ]_]^\b \_`  fXdc ¡k k k rXb ^ rXf^¢ r

4 r ]_i m3]_i\f ]_i 4 eald iZ_ j noopq 3]_ i\f j 4 ealdiZ_ j 6 r r ¡ noop¢ r fX`\a`Z_^ b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e ]^]Z_e` b ][ZaZXde lXe`e r y_ Z^_] j  rj \iZ`Xf j

      j _db Y \f nƒ no Z_  \a`df\ { X`\e Z_ 6Xb cd`\f 3aZ\_ a\ r 3cfZ_^\fh \f[]^ r m \g]b ] ]_i W ]i\Zf] j ‚‚ nq \g]b ] j
r ]_i W ]i\Zf] j
r 5 r W r ¡‚‚ n¢ r 1 _ ]d`Xb ]`\i _\^Xh `Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ sXf \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ r y_  

   
  
   
 

   
    j  ][[]e j 4  j

31 r

m `X ]_ i  ]l ]Y j ‚‚ nq `X j { r ]_i  ]l]Y j 5 r ¡‚‚ n¢ r 3dfu\g eXYf\ e\^df]_ a] i\ eZe`\b ]e i\ ]^\_`\e b Xu\Ze  r 4\al_Za][ 5 \c Xf` y6h‚ nh‚p j y_e`Zh `d`X i\ 6Xb cd`] a]X h _Za]b c j 6]b cZ_]e j 3 j 2 f] Z[ r mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q t Z[l\[b j r  rj 3`]]b ]__ j 3 r W rj ]_i 2 d``g]_ j  r ¡‚‚‚¢r 1 c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al `X `fde` Z_ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` c[]`sXfb e r     
  j c]^\e ƒ‚  ƒp r m}\\ ]_i 4g^]f j noo~q }\\ j 2 r ]_i 4g^]f j
r  r ¡ noo~¢ r 3\adf\ aXcfX a\eeXfe Z_ \[\a`fX_Za aXb h b \fa\ ]cc[Za]`ZX_e r y_          

    

 j { \k }Xfz j {} j 31 r

3
{ y r