Getting the Land Back “Legislation will always be forced to adapt itself to the imperative wants of society.” (Karl Marx, “The Abolition of Landed Property,” 1869)

In South Africa, such discussion as there is of the “land back” question, is done without the benefit of any consideration of the political economy of the land as it is, or as it could be in any foreseeable future. Without the realisation that we are still in a class-divided society, reproduction of the prevailing class divisions during and after land distribution is inevitable. The “land back” question would then have to be treated as capable of being satisfied by proxy. In other words, the existence of a minority of rich blacks on the land would be held to satisfy, by proxy, the land-hunger of the vast majority of blacks who will never be rich farmers, or landowners of any kind. These difficulties in the “land back” matter have not begun to be discussed publicly in South Africa. Who will actually get the land? Who will be the masters on the land, and who their servants? In his letter to Robert Applegarth of 3 December 1869, on “The Abolition of Landed Property,” Karl Marx says, among other things, that "The future will decide that the land cannot be owned but nationally.” He did not mean that it would then be portioned out, whether as freehold or leasehold.

“To nationalize the land and let it out in small plots to individuals or workingmen's societies would, under a middle-class government, only bring about a reckless competition among them, and cause a certain increase of ‘rent’, and thus lend new facilities to the appropriators for feeding upon the producers,” said Marx. A deliberate return to feudalism is equally impossible to contemplate, or more so. Feudalism still exists in South Africa, but in a corrupted form that is really no more than a disguised form of private ownership. There is no way back there. Without a new determination of the form of ownership, all that can happen is an extension, or reproduction, of the current relations of production on the land. In these circumstances, what is practically inevitable is “new facilities to the appropriators for feeding upon the producers” as Marx put it in the same letter to Applegarth. These “appropriators” are the bankers and others with command of financial resources. In South Africa, the appropriators are white. Even if the imagined new major landowners – black proxy landholders on behalf of the black masses – come into being, they will be beholden to existing, white, sources of finance. Thus, “getting the land back” could be a bonanza – for whites! Who is going to lead the necessary discussion about all this? The demagogues will not. The ANC could possibly do so, but has not yet. Once again we appear to need the good offices of Prof. Steven Friedman! VC

Getting the Land Back -

Getting the Land Back. “Legislation will always be forced to adapt itself to the imperative wants of society.” (Karl Marx, “The Abolition of Landed Property,” 1869).

962KB Sizes 1 Downloads 165 Views

Recommend Documents

'Landlords Taking Back the Land'? - Springer Link
ISSN 0957-8811 print/ISSN 1743-9728 online .... well as, to a lesser degree, inadequate investment and international sanctions ... degrees, further liberalised. .... of welfare such as health indicators, education indicators [Glewe et al., 2000] and,

Back to the land: the paradox of organic food standards - CiteSeerX
Padel, 1994) and provides economic space to remunerate the `real' social costs of ... creates economic rentsöoverprofits in the marketing of some products based on ... dards, certification schemes, and labels all enable ``action at a distance'' ....

The Importance of Professional Land Surveyor in The Land ...
Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. The Importance of Professional Land Surveyor in The Land Development Process.pdf.

The Back Page
Sep 29, 2008 - Although he has spoken on the record generally about broadband, ... Kennard's plan calls for Obama to create a new agency and appoint a ...

The Back Page
Feb 9, 2010 - The goal of universal broadband enjoys broad bipartisan ... Internet, and Representative Lee Terry (R-NE) appears to be going nowhere in the ...

The Back Page
Oct 6, 2008 - The Back Page. Analysis and Commentary for the Independent Telecommunications Industry. Published By Independent Telecom Associates.

The Back Page
Aug 3, 2009 - analysts thought the Obama administration would make .... economic stimulus measure to the pending health care reform legislation – the new president seems ... large carriers would use the broadband grant program to expand their broad

Getting Around the City
Getting Around the City. Written by Kira Freed • Illustrated by Fred Volke ... I go to my friend's house. I go on my skateboard. My sister goes to school. She goes ...

Getting Around the City
My sister goes to school. She goes on a bike. 4. Getting Around the City • Level D. 3. Page 4. My mom goes to work. She goes in a car. My dad goes to work.

Research Trails: Getting Back Where You Left Off - Research at Google
It shows the user's research trails as selectable and manipulable visual streams when they open a new tab. Thereby ... qualifications that she was missing and searching for classes that she could take, while she continued .... propose an interaction

Getting Back to Basics Series Flyer 12-19-17.pdf
Page 1 of 1. Mental Health Association in Orange County, Inc. Presents. Getting Back to Basics Series. Bring your lunch and refresh on the fundamentals! The series continues with: Medication Treatment in Autism Spectrum Disorders. This presentation w

Back to the 80s Flyer.pdf
Page 2 of 2. Alan Marcus, D.D.S.. American Girl. Bacchus Wine. BashaMichi Japanese Bistro. Beach Blanket Babylon. Bel Mateo Bowl. Books Inc. Brett Baker – ...

The Underdog is Back
In India, the RBI appears willing to give the incoming government some space to implement reforms and has put its hiking cycle on hold despite inflation still running at target with ..... J.P. Morgan uses the following rating system: Overweight [Over

The-Road-Back-A-Novel.pdf
Page 1 of 2. Download >>>