April 11, 2018 To: Re:

Members of the Senate Environmental Resources & Energy Committee Opposition to Senate Bill 1088 (P.N. 1546)

Dear Senators: The Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) and Pennsylvania Environmental Council (PEC) respectfully submit the following comments on Senate Bill 1088 (P.N. 1546), which we anticipate will come before the Senate Environmental Resources and Energy Committee for a vote early next week. At the start, we wish to express our appreciation to Senators Yaw and Hutchinson for allowing additional time for review and comment on this legislation. SB 1088 seeks to revert performance and protection standards for the conventional oil and gas industry, which were modernized with the bipartisan enactment of Act 13 of 2012. However, even today, that law has yet to be fully implemented by the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP), as the agency was directed by the General Assembly in 2016 to restart their rulemaking for the conventional industry. It is our understanding that DEP is poised to issue a revised proposal for public comment in the near future. SB 1088 would not only reverse protection standards from the 2012 law, it would actually be weaker in several important instances than the original 1984 Oil and Gas Act. Pennsylvania would have the discreditable distinction of being the only state in the country to walk back protections applied to oil and gas operations – whether conventional or unconventional. In fact, the way certain provisions are worded in this legislation, this bill could potentially weaken standards applied to unconventional operations as well. Both EDF and PEC believe that any potential divergence in standards must be based on the practices and technologies employed at a well site, as well as objective risk assessment. Unfortunately, SB 1088 is a blunt instrument that fails against both of these metrics. This legislation contradicts leading industry practices as articulated in API standards and recommended practices. Under Act 13, and as defined in SB 1088, the fundamental distinction between “conventional” and “unconventional” operations is one based on depth of drilling. “Conventional” wells can be drilled horizontally, and in many cases are hydraulically fractured at much shallower formations in closer proximity to groundwater – a fact this legislation clearly acknowledges. In other words, the legal distinction in Pennsylvania is made irrespective to the size of the operator or operation, the practices employed at the well site, or the associated risks involved. Any law that alters protection standards should only do so where the actual operations at the well site allow. In our view, any well that employs high volume hydraulic fracturing should be subjected to stringent and uniform control. Other states follow this distinction for their application of standards – for example, the state of Illinois, which utilizes “high volume horizontal hydraulic fracturing operations”1 as a threshold. Pennsylvania should do the same.

1

See 225 ILCS 732, Article 1, Section 1-5

Beyond this fundamental problem, there are several other major concerns with SB1088 including, but not limited to: • •



• • • • • •

Removal of language that requires additional analysis of potential impacts to Public Resources. This language was in the 1984 law, reinforced by Act 13, and validated by the Pennsylvania courts. Removal of any requirement for operators to disclose chemicals used in the fracturing process. Disclosure – for both conventional and unconventional operators – is currently required practice in Pennsylvania as well as in virtually all other jurisdictions in the United States, and it should remain that way. Removing storage, spill, and leak prevention provisions, despite the fact that conventional sites present spill and leak threats similar to unconventional operations. In fact, this legislation provides express exemptions from the state’s Storage Tank and Spill Prevention Act, and dramatically weakens spill and leak reporting requirements. Exempting certain existing wastewater treatment facilities from state water protection requirements, even though those protections have been applied for years. Weakening protections for impacted drinking water supplies, including failure to ensure that, in all instances, replacement supplies meet the standards of the Safe Drinking Water Act. Reducing setback provisions from homes, buildings, and surface waters. Weakening well integrity standards that are critical for groundwater protection. As was already invalidated by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 2013, attempting to preempt local ordinances that address issues associated with oil and gas activities. Maintaining woefully inadequate bonding and financial assurance requirements, which leaves Pennsylvanians on the hook for costly remediation work in the decades to come.

Conclusion Senate Bill 1088 is a wholesale weakening of necessary protection standards; standards that are already the law in Pennsylvania, and that are accepted common practice in the industry and other oil and gas producing states. It also contradicts recent decisions of the Pennsylvania courts that have upheld protections on both statutory and constitutional grounds. For these reasons, we strongly urge you to oppose this bill. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Andrew Williams Director, Regulatory and Legislative Affairs, U.S. Climate and Energy Environmental Defense Fund John Walliser Senior Vice President, Legal & Government Affairs Pennsylvania Environmental Council

EDF PEC SB1088 Comments. 11 April 2018.pdf

was directed by the General Assembly in 2016 to restart their rulemaking for the conventional industry. It is our understanding that DEP is ... Pennsylvania Environmental Council. Page 2 of 2. EDF PEC SB1088 Comments. 11 April 2018.pdf. EDF PEC SB1088 Comments. 11 April 2018.pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In.

57KB Sizes 0 Downloads 163 Views

Recommend Documents

EDF PEC HB2154 Comments. 30 April 2018.pdf
Weakening well integrity standards that are critical for groundwater protection [Section 307 of the. legislation, page 27]. • Preserving woefully inadequate ...

PEC EDF House Regulatory Legislation Letter. 30 April 2018 (1).pdf ...
3 days ago - The General Assembly already has ample authority to review and act on. regulations. In our view, the Commonwealth is better served by advancing inclusive, constructive. dialogue on shared goals instead of legislation that will only foste

11 April 2017 - SETTRADE.COM
Apr 11, 2017 - Open. Gold. 1257.20. 1247.00. 1253.76. 1254.23. A.M.Fixing. -. -. -. 1253. P.M.Fixing ... Euro. 1.0606. 1.0568. 1.0590. 1.0593. Baht. 34.67. 34.57. 34.61. DollarIndex 101.340 .... Bank Holiday : Good Friday. -. -. 19.30 . (CPI) .

PEC DEFINITIVO 13-11-09.pdf
Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. PEC DEFINITIVO 13-11-09.pdf. PEC DEFINITIVO 13-11-09.pdf.

April 11 2017.pdf
... Petrie, Superintendent; Mr. Mason, Treasurer; Mr. Mills, High/MS Principal, Mrs. ... Terry Lichtenburg Aide (4 hours per day) Aide Step 0. 3. ... April 11 2017.pdf.

Nora Mitchell April 11, 2017 - GitHub
Apr 11, 2017 - It estimates effective population sizes and past migration rates between populations ... Which model has the highest support? Which would you.

April 11 Alert SBI.pdf
Action Five: Social Media. Twitter: Access your member of Congress' twitter handle at http://stuffthought.com/blog/113th-congress-twitter-handles/. Sample ...

April 11, 2018 Board Minutes.pdf
Approve Resignation of Justin Johnson as Teacher and Coach for 2018-19 School. Year. c. Approve Resignation of Shelly Berkowitz as K-8 Art Teacher for ...

PEC .pdf
Crank dualaudio eng hindi.Fatestay ... Inside Comedy S04E0.Ironman 2 ... PEC .pdf. PEC .pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In. Details. Comments. General ...

PEC CFATORRENTMELIS.pdf
There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item.

Access 2_3 pec Sheet
Page 1. Specifications. LOA. 2.3M. Beam. 1.25M. Draft. 0.9M. Sail. 3.8sqM. Hull. 52Kg. Keel. 20Kg. International Access 2.3.

Access 2_3 pec Sheet
Page 1. Specifications. LOA. 3.60M. Beam. 1.35M. Draft. 1.10M. Main. 5.60sqM. Jib. 1.75sqM. Hull. 72Kg. Keel. 72Kg. Access Liberty.

Editorial comments
On 23 June 2016, 51.9 percent of the electorate in the United Kingdom decided in a referendum that the UK should leave the European Union. The turnout was ...

pec-pet_schedule01.pdf
45 6162060770 YELIGIREDDY CHAITANYA KUMAR REDDY. 46 6162060785 SUNKARABOINA KIRAN KUMAR. 47 6162060919 NENAVATH RAMULU. 48 6162061189 SURIKANTI CHANDRA PRAKASH. 49 6162061995 K RAMESH REDDY. 50 6162062495 LINGAMPALLY MOHAN RAJ. 51 6162063433 ESLAVATH

Primary EyeCare (PEC)_Member.pdf
mark, of Vision Service Plan. Questions? vsp.com | 800.877.7195. 100%. SATISFACTION. GUARANTEED. Page 1 of 1. Primary EyeCare (PEC)_Member.pdf.

Chamada - PEC-PG - 2015.pdf
CHAMADA CNPq no 05/2015 ... encaminhadas ao CNPq exclusivamente via Internet, por intermédio do Formulário de ... 800-FDA-1088.. voltaren dolo extra mg; voltaren gel 120 mg zu risiken und ... Intensive Care Manual. ... Author:Verizon.

Park Master Plan Alternate - April 11, 2016.pdf
Osborne Park A. Monumental Park Sign – (1Qty.) $5,000.00. Sub-Total $5,000.00. 25% Contingency $1,300.00. Estimated Total $6,300.00. Revised - Proposed ...

NSE/SURV/37491 Date: April 11, 2018 Circul
Apr 11, 2018 - segment (series: BE) to rolling segment (series: EQ) with effect from April 20, 2018 (Friday). For National Stock Exchange of India Limited.

BA, Agenda, April 11, 2017.pdf
Page 1 of 1. To view the agenda on-line with the attached staff reports go to: http://casagrandeaz.us/dept/clerk/boards/boa/. AGENDA. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT. MEETING. Tuesday, April 11, 2017 at 6:00 p.m.. City Hall Council Chambers - 510 E. Florence Bou

EE6301 PEC ECE_OOPSDS_Unit-1 - 5- By EasyEngineering.net.pdf ...
Page 3 of 261. EE6301 PEC ECE_OOPSDS_Unit-1 - 5- By EasyEngineering.net.pdf. EE6301 PEC ECE_OOPSDS_Unit-1 - 5- By EasyEngineering.net.pdf.

City Council Meeting – April 11, 2017 1441st ...
Apr 11, 2017 - dedicated service to the City of Thornton. [580-GE]. 2. A resolution conveying the City Council's gratitude and appreciation to. Scott Twombly for ...

NSE/CML/34615 Date : April 11, 2017 Circular Ref
Apr 11, 2017 - ISIN Code. Series. Reason for. Suspension ... of India Limited. Kautuk Upadhyay. Manager. Telephone No. Fax No. Email id. 022-26598235/36.

NSE/CML/34611 Date : April 11, 2017 Circular Re
Apr 11, 2017 - This circular shall be effective from April 18, 2017. For and on ... Divya Poojari. Manager. Telephone No. Fax No. Email id. 022-26598235/36.

BOE Minutes - April 11, 2017.pdf
Shepard (via skype). MEMBERS ABSENT: None. OTHERS PRESENT: L. Ford, B. Ellsworth, T. Reidell, M. Catalina, K. McFarland, C. Williams, C. Adamczyk, L.