DO ARBITRAGE FREE PRICES COME FROM UTILITY MAXIMIZATION? Pietro Siorpaes

Ann Arbor, May 2011

IT DEPENDS

ALWAYS SELL

MARKET ARBITRAGE FREE PRICES ALWAYS BUY

IT DEPENDS

ALWAYS SELL

MARKET + AGENT MARGINAL PRICES BUY

DO NOTHING

SELL

MARGINAL PRICES

Agent u(x, q)

maximal expected utility achievable

x

initial cash wealth

q

initial number of cont. claims

Marginal Prices Intuitive definition p is a marginal price for the agent with utility u and initial endowment (x, q) if his optimal demand of cont. claims at price p is zero.

MARGINAL PRICES Agent u(x, q)

maximal expected utility

x

cash wealth

q

number of cont. claims

Marginal Prices Definition of MP(x, q; u) p is a marginal price at (x, q) relative to u if u(x − pq 0 , q + q 0 ) ≤ u(x, q)

for all q 0 ∈ Rn ,

i.e. if (x, q) maximizes u over {(x − pq 0 , q + q 0 ) : q 0 ∈ Rn } =: A

QUESTIONS

1

Are marginal prices always arbitrage free ? MP(x, q; u) ⊆ AFP

?

QUESTIONS

1

Are marginal prices always arbitrage free ? MP(x, q; u) ⊆ AFP K ARATZAS

AND

KOU (1996)

?

QUESTIONS

1

Are marginal prices always arbitrage free ? MP(x, q; u) ⊆ AFP K ARATZAS

2

AND

?

KOU (1996)

Do all arbitrage free prices come from utility maximization? [

Union over what ?

MP(x, q; u) ⊇ AFP

?

THE MODEL Market S Stocks Bank account with no interest Exist martingale measures No constraints on strategy H

THE MODEL Market S Stocks Bank account with no interest Exist martingale measures No constraints on strategy H Agent Maximal expected utility u(x, q) := sup E[U(x + qf + H

U : (0, ∞) → R

Z

T 0

HdS)]

Utility: strictly concave, increasing, differentiable, Inada conditions

ARBITRAGE FREE PRICES Contingent claims f (ω) ∈ Rn |f | ≤ c +

RT 0

random payoff HdS

qf is not replicable

for some c, H for any q 6= 0

Arbitrage free prices Definition of AFP p is an arbitrage free price if q 0 (f − p) +

RT 0

HdS ≥ 0

implies

q 0 (f − p) +

RT 0

HdS = 0

MAIN THEOREM Theorem If supx (u(x, 0) − xy ) < ∞ [

for all

y >0

then

MP(x, q; u) = AFP

(x,q)∈{u>−∞}

u(x, 0) = u(x) as in Kramkov and Schachermayer (1999) Marginal prices are always arbitrage free, and vice versa Any U is enough to reconstruct AFP

TECHNICAL POINTS

Not enough to consider (x, q) in the interior of {u > −∞} Study u on the boundary of {u > −∞}, and prove its upper semi-continuity New geometrical characterization of AFP:

Lemma If u(x, q) > −∞, then p ∈ AFP iff A ∩ {u > −∞} is bounded, where A = {(x − pq 0 , q + q 0 ) : q 0 ∈ Rn }.

DOMAIN OF UTILITY u

q u∈R

u = −∞

x

P ARBITRAGE FREE PRICE

B

u = −∞

u∈R (x,q)

A := {(x − pq 0 , q + q 0 ) : q 0 ∈ Rn } p ∈ MP(x, q; u) if (x, q) is maximizer of u on B

P ARBITRAGE PRICE

B u∈R u = −∞ 

(x,q)

A := {(x − pq 0 , q + q 0 ) : q 0 ∈ Rn } p ∈ MP(x, q; u) if (x, q) is maximizer of u on B

## do arbitrage free prices come from utility maximization?

Bank account with no interest. Exist martingale measures. No constraints on strategy H. Agent. Maximal expected utility u(x,q) := sup. H. E[U(x + qf + â« T. 0.

#### Recommend Documents

Where Do the Elements Come From Worksheet.pdf
anthony fernandez. nasa. Page 3 of 3. Where Do the Elements Come From Worksheet.pdf. Where Do the Elements Come From Worksheet.pdf. Open. Extract.

Conditions on option prices for absence of arbitrage ...
spreads, let us try to give some intuition on the conditions call prices should satisfy .... Finally, the options are cash settled: one, who holds a call, receives in cash the .... of the statistical measure, which are never known in advance (see Rem

Convergence of utility indifference prices to the ...
utility free concept. It is the ... The authors thank their laboratories for hosting this research. The visit of ..... What happens when the domain is the whole real axis?

Optimal strategies and utility-based prices converge ...
analytic machinery has been developed, see Kramkov and Schachermayer ..... mayer [18]), we should find bounds on the solution which would involve the set.

Where do social relations come from? A study of ...
tions of pairs and triads in response to certain favorable conditions, e.g. luck, leadership, ... people met in earlier settings, such as school or the army; only rarely do chance meetings, in a bar ..... Grafmeyer, Y. (Eds.), La Famille Et Ses Proch

Do Energy Prices Influence Investment in Energy ... - Semantic Scholar
They find little evidence that the price premium for a green home .... used for electronics, new homes, commercial buildings, and industrial plants. It should ... were Energy Star products for each of four major appliances: air-conditioners, clothes.

Do Energy Prices Influence Investment in Energy ... - Semantic Scholar
Houde (2014) develops a structural model of the U.S. refrigerator market and finds that consumers respond to both energy costs and efficiency labels, though substantial heterogeneity in the nature of the response exists across house- holds. The key d