Hydro-Testing or EMI Scanning? – Making Sense (… and dollars) Out of Production Pipe Issues Introduction This paper addresses a common misconception regarding the field testing and inspection of oilfield production tubing. It seems that Electromagnetic Inspection (EMI) has been promoted as a modern replacement for the well established hydrostatic method of testing oilfield tubulars. Although EMI has improved dramatically over the past 50 years, it is still only half of the tubing integrity equation. What were once considered alternative methods are actually complementary steps in a comprehensive flaw detection program.

Background New technologies in oil and gas exploration continue to stretch the limits of production tubing. Increases in temperatures and pressure, corrosive gases, and deeper, deviated well bores make pipe integrity more critical today than ever before. As conditions become even more extreme, oilfield tubulars will continue to dramatically affect the production capability of every oil and gas well. A study of over 32,000 wells in the U.S. has revealed that tubing problems account for 42% of all well failures. This would indicate that nearly half of all losses incurred from well failure could be avoided if defective and potentially defective pipes were removed from the well bore, not to mention production efficiency losses that have not yet degraded to complete well failure.

Reasons for Pulling Tubing Tubing Leaks/Failures 42.3% Pump 17% Acid, Frac,Etc 9.9% Well Cleanout 8.7% Rod Failure 7.7% Other 14.5%

Advanced Hydrostatic Services, L.L.C.

888-HYDRO-TX

Page 1

That same survey found that corrosive pitting, rod wear, and wall loss are the major causes of tubing failure. Depending on severity and location, these problems are identified in the field using hydrostatic pressure testing or electromagnetic inspection. Each process has strengths and limitations that should be examined to determine the proper pipe integrity strategy.

Reasons for Tubing Failure Corrosion Pitting 44% Rod Wear 37% Connections/Threads 16% Other 3%

Hydrostatic testing has been used in the oilfield for well over 50 years. It is a full joint test that is capable of detecting a variety of flaws and leaks. When employed above Maximum Operating Pressure (MOP), hydrostatic testing is an excellent indication of pipe integrity. Unlike other technologies, hydro-testing is able to locate defects in the upset, collars, and threads. Performing this test as pipe is run into the hole is especially useful because the connections are verified as they will be during production. For example, if the well servicing crew happens to over/under torque a connection, the resulting leak is easily identified by the hydrostatic operator. The most obvious limitation of hydrostatic testing is its “pass or fail” nature. If it were known that a section of pipe barely passed the hydrostatic test, it would make sense to remove it from the production string. Lacking that capability, it is advantageous to find a complementary method to determine long term sustainability. Electromagnetic Inspection, in its primitive form, has been in use since the mid 1950’s. Modern flux leakage based systems eliminated the problems associated with radioactive components and the need for sensors to remain in contact with the pipe. Improving technology has also allowed for multiple flaw detection channels and 360 degree full body coverage. Although the technology for true high-speed wall thickness measurement is still several years away, EMI is very effective at detecting subtle and abrupt changes in wall thickness along the body of the pipe. Once an indication is given, an ultrasonic device is used to measure the actual wall loss. In theory, a spot check of an infinite number of points on the surface of each pipe with an ultrasound device would produce better data than a magnetic flux crosssection, but using EMI scanning to locate anomalies for ultrasonic verification is far less time consuming and thereby more cost effective. The limitations of EMI scanning vary, depending on the standard to which it is being held. When compared for the purposes of replacing a hydrostatic test, the “body wall only” coverage and reduced ability to detect flaws smaller than 3/16” and splits less than 3” would seem like a drawback. When examined in light of its primary purpose (wall loss monitoring), any significant flaw detection capability could be viewed as an additional benefit.

Advanced Hydrostatic Services, L.L.C.

888-HYDRO-TX

Page 2

Combined Flaw Detection Coverage Hydrostatic Testing Wall Thickness Variations

EMI Scanning 

Resulting Coverage 

Collar Defects





Thread Defects





Upset Defects





Body defects > 3/16”







Body Splits > 3”







Small Body Defects





Solution Only through an honest assessment of each technology’s limitations can we begin to understand the benefit of their complementary relationship. While hydrostatic testing identifies leaks and flaws that will negatively affect today’s production, EMI scanning ensures that wall thickness issues relating to rod wear and corrosion will not jeopardize future output. This combination of services provides a comprehensive view of both short term and long term tubing integrity. Waiting for tubing problems to cause well failure increases the likelihood of inefficient production until the actual failure occurs. A preventive maintenance strategy ensures that the well bore is producing at maximum efficiency at all times. This also means a significant savings in workover costs by taking advantage of the opportunity to test and scan tubing pulled out of the hole for other purposes. This is one area where production gains and expense savings are possible simultaneously. From a return on investment perspective, the average cost of testing and scanning once each year is less than a barrel per week. In a Forest Oil gas lift well, finding holes or leaks in the tubing string increased production from 41 BOPD to 220 BOPD 1 (over 500%). While this outcome is certainly not typical, it speaks to the critical role that tubing plays in getting product to the surface.

Our Services Advanced Hydrostatic Services offers testing and scanning services in Central and South Texas. Our hydrostatic test units are the most versatile in the industry, able to test both downhole and on the rack. We utilize the latest 6 channel, non-contact EMI technology to achieve the best possible flaw detection. With 360 degrees of non-radioactive coverage, our inspection system sets the industry standard. Please contact us at 888-HYDRO-TX or [email protected] to learn more about how our services can help you achieve your production goals. Also, visit us online at www.AdvancedHydrostatic.com.

1

Weatherford. 2012.

Advanced Hydrostatic Services, L.L.C.

888-HYDRO-TX

Page 3

AHS white paper r1.pdf

Page 1 of 3. Hydro-Testing or EMI Scanning? – Making. Sense (... and dollars) Out of Production Pipe. Issues. Introduction. This paper addresses a common ...
Missing:

161KB Sizes 2 Downloads 327 Views

Recommend Documents

AHS white paper r1.pdf
Page 1 of 3. Page 1 of 3. Page 2 of 3. VULKANEUM SCHOTTEN. PROJEKTFORTSCHRITT „MUSEOGRAFIE“. September 2014 Wettbewerbskonzept. Dezember 2014 / Januar 2015 Vorentwurf. Februar bis April 2015 Entwurf. Page 2 of 3. Page 3 of 3. 17. wlucb rbd3 ihe b

white paper
50 percent to 83 percent and there is no cap on the total Federal financial ...... project, the Medicare Participating Heart Bypass Center demonstration, was ..... rules, proceedings, and reports and make them available on a public Internet site. Its

White Paper - GitHub
manual labor was replaced by the machine. The second .... 6.1 M-POS Mode. With the revolution of eth——the introduced pos mode, the pos mode of block chain will also usher in a new spring. HDSS absorbs the advantages and .... architecture and futu

Overview & White Paper - Electroneum
market. This overview paper outlines in detail the concept and planning behind Electroneum ... listed on the London Stock Exchange, Mark .... 3G or 4G data.

White Paper - Neuromation
Oct 2, 2017 - decentralized networks. He is an entrepreneur, visionary, guru, author, blogger, keynote speaker, and thought leader of the global technology.

White Paper 2
Jan 7, 2005 - The best tilt angle for any PV array is the one ... Triple-Junction, amorphous silicon PV array would be .... Insolation level (W/m2) or (Whr/m2).

White Paper 1
designed to provide a renewable energy power source to ... DC-Efficiency vs Irradiation. 3.5 kWp Triple Junction (UNI-SOLAR. ®. ) 0. 2. 4. 6. 8. 10. 0. 200. 400.

White Paper 1
The performance data from this large- ... system was equipped with data acquisition equipment that allows both ..... Rainfall and periodic cleanings restore the.

White Paper 1
this paper provides an in-depth analysis of “real world” performance for ... The paper includes a description of the installed system, the basis for the system design and system architecture, and an analysis of the performance data. Performance o

White Paper SwissBorg.pdf
The scope of SwissBorg is beyond our own view. Indeed, we will abet the community to build. itself by bringing guidance and the best of breed financial practices. By doing so, our MAST. (meritocracy, accessibility, Swiss made and trusted) philosophy

Pearl Wallet White Paper - GitHub
messaging, EOS wallet management, mobile payment, and distributed ... Nowadays, mobile apps are leading a big trend, there are over 3.2 billion mobile ... Pearl Wallet White Paper. 1. Summary. 1. Table of Contents. 2. Core features and advantages of

AIIM White Paper
and document outsourcing services digitize and manage ... integrated approach to ECM. We look at the approach ..... distribution across Web sites. This will ...

White Paper SwissBorg.pdf
The Lack of Innovation in Wealth Management 2 ... combination of self-learning algorithms, swarm intelligence and smart contracts ... White Paper SwissBorg.pdf.

Enterprise Image Management white paper - Esri
Attention: Contracts and Legal Services Manager, Esri, 380 New York Street, ..... Focused, feature-rich web, mobile, and desktop applications that enable the ... Esri White Paper. 3. The same server-based capabilities are also accessible to ...

MetaProp Advisors White Paper FINAL.pdf
Ryan Sullivan, CEO & Co-Founder, Parkifi. Page 3 of 6. MetaProp Advisors White Paper FINAL.pdf. MetaProp Advisors White Paper FINAL.pdf. Open. Extract.

JADE A White Paper
FINALLY, THE MAIN FEATS OF THE JADE APPROACH ARE SUMMED UP, WITH .... ster or Gnutella) or a multiplayer game, require ... of another user: the server is not necessary but it is .... an agent platform and a set of services that should.

PayPro | White Paper V2.4.pdf
3. CONTENT. I. Vision. II. Concept. III. Technology. IV. ICO. V. Team. Page 3 of 40. PayPro | White Paper V2.4.pdf. PayPro | White Paper V2.4.pdf. Open. Extract.

Eitcoin-White-Paper-[EN].pdf
There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. Eitcoin-White-Paper-[EN].pdf. Eitcoin-White-Paper-[EN].pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In. Main menu.

Cure53 Browser Security White Paper - GitHub
Table 31. Security Zones Support . ... Number of DOM Properties exposed in window . ...... the funding body - namely Google's Chrome - was not given any preferential treatment .... systems, as well as contain browsers for feature phones and embedded

Vireo White Paper - Phase II.pdf
Page 1 of 25. White Paper. Phase II. Vireo AM Products &. Vireo Seed Initial Security Token. Offering (ISTO). v3.2 - February 2018. Investors will be required to pass the KYC & AML accreditation process before. buying Vireo Security Tokens. Only qual

NGMN 5G White Paper
Feb 17, 2015 - objectives of the program, by providing the necessary guidance to the team to deliver the White ...... goes beyond what 4G and its enhancements can support. .... proliferation of cloud-based services will enable application ... enterpr

White Paper .pdf 5.36 mb - Longcatchain
Feb 1, 2018 - With the advancement of modern medicine and the prolonging of human life, populations have grown exponentially. This has led to an increased demand for housing and has become a problem faced by all countries across the globe. In the adv

Steem White Paper Chinese Translation - GitHub
Page 1 ... Facebook Twitter 2014 Reddit reddit.com1 Reddit. Steem. Steem .... The new marketplace Popularity Head Long Tail Products. Steem Steem Power ...